"So where ARE we taking him?" Amy asked Katherine as they practically carried Alan up the stairs.
"I dunno. Maybe my bedroom. That might give us some privacy."
"Or here." Amy opened the door to the seldom-used guest room, which was the closest room to the stairs on the upper floor. "It's closer and there's no phone."
"Excellent!" Katherine guided Alan in. "Now the big question is, who gets to be fucked first?"
"Nope," Alan said, holding his hard-on to keep it from bouncing around. "I don't want to waste one second arguing about that. The phone calls were torture enough. I'm horny! I want you two to lie on the bed in a fuck sandwich and dangle your legs over the edge of the bed so I can stand next to it and plow into the pair of you with wanton abandon. Can you do that?"
"Fuck sandwich!" Amy yelled enthusiastically as she threw herself onto the bed.
Katherine also made a big leap.
"I take it that's a 'Yes,'" he said with amused understatement.
The girls wasted no time in getting into "sandwich" position, with Katherine on top.
As Alan got into position, he said, "Aims, I know you said you wanted it in the ass, but I'm just too horny to go through all the prep work. We both know how deliciously tight you are back there, and getting into your ass kind of requires a big production. Besides, I shouldn't go back and forth from vaginal to anal 'cos of the whole infection worry."
"That's cool." She giggled as she added, "I'll forgive you if you poke me first!"
He chuckled. "One Amy poke, coming up!" He guided his erection into her moist slit. But even her pussy was extremely tight, so he couldn't just thrust in all the way on the first push. He had to wiggle his way in with a series of short thrusts, each one making a little more headway. There was a lot of grunting and groaning involved, but it was intensely pleasurable, too.
However, he knew that Katherine was even more anxious and needy than Amy right then, if such a thing was possible. And her moans of desire were a loud reminder that she needed to be serviced too.
So as soon as he'd achieved maximum penetration in Amy, he pulled out and plunged into his other sister. That was a faster process, but not that easy since she was quite tight too.
After he finally made it all the way in, he rested from all the exertion. He grunted, "Why do my two sisters have the two tightest pussies in the entire universe?"
Katherine gleefully answered, "To better serve you as fuck toys! Duh! He really is a thick one, isn't he, Aims?"
Amy giggled. "He IS!"
Katherine giggled too as she finally caught her own double meaning. "Oh yeah. In more ways than one!"
He slid in and out of Katherine a few times, just enough to open her up so he could plunge back in a lot easier the next time.
Then he switched back to Amy and really went to town on her. He fucked her good, with strong, deep thrusts for a minute or two.
Then he did the same to Katherine.
As he did so, Amy said, "I just loooove fuck sandwiches! They're so neat-o! I especially like being on the bottom. That's super cool. I get to feel more of the fucking vibrations when it's not my turn, y'know? You hear how my voice is all shaky? That's from the second-hand fuck!"
As Alan switched holes again, he said, "That may be, normally, but we'll see how you like this one. I was just getting warmed up, and now I'm REALLY gonna start slamming. So it might get pretty rough down there, with all that weight bouncing on you."
"M'kay! Sounds like fun! Let's do it!"
He did just as he promised and began plunging in and out of Amy's tight slit with all the energy he could muster. And because he was still surging with adrenaline from the fight, that was a lot of energy. Katherine began to look like a ship being tossed around on a stormy sea as Amy writhed wildly underneath her.
Then he switched and did the same to Katherine. "Oh GAAWWWD!" she screamed as he stabbed his pole all the way into her with one thrust.
"Feels good, huh?" Amy asked. She stared up into her sister's eyes from mere inches away.
"You know it!" Impulsively, Katherine bent her head down and kissed Amy on the lips as Alan began his hard thrusting. She thought, I feel like SUCH a fuck toy! I love getting it at both ends at once!
But the kissing had to stop in less than a minute after the fucking got rough because Katherine was struggling just to breathe.
Then Alan switched again. He kept switching every couple of minutes, seemingly building up even more energy and thrusting power each time he did so.
Susan and Suzanne knew they'd both been a bit "cock hoggy" lately, but as the screams of pleasure from the guest room grew louder and louder, they simply couldn't stay away. They quietly opened the door and peeked in, eager to watch without interrupting.
Alan and his sisters didn't even notice their observers because he was fucking so relentlessly. Normally, by this time he would already have paused for a strategic break or two, but he didn't want to pause any more than he was forced to as he switched from one pussy to another. He wanted to raise the crescendo higher and higher until they all passed out from sheer pleasure.
His challenge though was that each time he was nailing one sister, the other was having a strategic break of her own. So, although it was difficult to multitask when he was in an animalistic mood, before long he began fingerfucking one pussy while his dick was in the other. He clumped his fingers together and rammed them in and out just like he had another stiff penis, although obviously he couldn't go nearly as deep or deliver the same level of pleasure.
But for the girls, such differences didn't seem to matter much. They both felt like they were being fucked non-stop, with only the briefest of pauses every now and then for the few seconds it took him to switch holes.
Susan and Suzanne watched in awe. They knew exactly how the girls were feeling since they'd just been treated to the same kind of fucking a short time before. Every grunt, every moan, every thrust practically felt like it was happening to them instead.
The two mothers were talking quietly to each other, and their mutterings finally caused Alan to look up and notice that they were there.
Seeing the eye contact, Susan said, "Son, I know you're a bit preoccupied at the moment, to say the least, but I just have to say: Wow! WOW! I'm just so PROUD of you, proud of the way you're fucking your sisters, laying your big log in them! What a GOOD son! I love you so much!"
"Me too!" Suzanne agreed. "Look, Susan, just look at him go! What I wouldn't give to be on the receiving end of that right now!"
"I KNOW! Suzanne, I just want to shout to the whole world that my son is my master! That he's the master of an incredible harem! He keeps all of us happy and well fucked! He's gonna make all four of his mommies and sisters cum at the same time! Is that incredible, or what?"
"It's incredible!" Suzanne's scratchy voice sounded genuinely awestruck.
Alan laughed. Once again, his reputation was doing a good deal of his "work" for him. His mothers were getting so excited just from watching and talking to each other that it was like he was fucking them hard too.
Suzanne started frigging Susan's pussy with the same clumped-together finger technique she was watching Alan use. Susan couldn't do the same to Suzanne since Suzanne's pussy was still recovering from Alan's brutal pounding, but she worked Suzanne's clit and nipples to very good effect.
Finally, Alan knew he could last no more. He was so far gone into his fucking that he didn't stop to think which girl he would shoot into. In fact he didn't even know which girl he was currently fucking; he just knew he was sliding in and out of an amazingly hot, tight, and wonderful hole. It so happened that he was balls-deep in Katherine when his cum started to fly.
One would have had to look very closely to notice, though, because both girls were screaming and cumming with great intensity. Amy was a renowned screamer, but Katherine was doing a very good job trying to match her.
It seemed that Alan's orgasm would never end. He just kept cumming and cumming, shooting spurt after spurt into Katherine's thoroughly-plowed furrow. And as long as he was cumming, both girls were cumming too.
In fact, Susan and Suzanne were cumming as well, inspired by watching and what they were doing to each other, so all five peaked at the same time.
Then, wham! Like a light being shut off, Alan gave up the struggle and collapsed onto Katherine. In his frenzy he'd lost track of just how intense the physical effort was, but now his body was paying the price. He was already sore with bruises, but he'd completely forgotten his pain while he was fucking. He'd even used his hands as usual without thinking about the wounds and bandages there. But now he felt even more sore and exhausted as he was left struggling just to breathe.
He was a bit disappointed that he hadn't fucked either girl to unconsciousness after putting in all that effort, but he figured that one can't hit a home run every time at bat. After a couple of minutes, he managed to roll off both girls after Amy's wiggles and grunts indicated she was being crushed by two bodies. Katherine then rolled off her.
The three lay on the bed side by side by side, recovering. "Wow..." Amy finally said.
Suzanne commented, "The word I think you're looking for is 'epic'. That's the word that came to mind for me after Sweetie just about destroyed my pussy out in the car."
That was the first the two girls had looked towards their mothers. "Yeah..." Amy said, still dazed and dreamy. "Epic. Super duper double wow epic." Her brain was too fried after that to think up one of her trademark long Amy words.
Katherine said, "What she said!" Then she looked at Amy and grinned as she added, "In fact, it was fan-epicadoodlearifficaroony-tastic!"
Amy burst into giggles at that. She leaned over and kissed Katherine on her nose. "Super cool sister!"
As Katherine started to recover a bit more, she said to her mothers, "Did you see what he was doing? It wasn't just a fuck sandwich, he was fucking us both at once! It was like he had two penises. This changes everything!"
Alan asked, "Changes everything? How?"
"We need more fuck sandwiches, for starters! You have soooo many fuck toys, and just one cock, but this doubles your fucking power! And I'll bet our moms had real good orgasms too, so it was like you slayed all four of us at once!"
His ego soared as he reveled in that accomplishment. But he said modestly, "Well, I don't know. I'm on this super energy trip, but that's just a one-time thing. It's not like I can do this kind of really physical fucking every day. Or even that I'd want to. Personally, I think I prefer the more intimate one-on-one slower kind."
Amy giggled and said, "Uh-oh! 'Good Alan' alert! 'Bad Alan' has left the building."
But Katherine rolled to her side so she could look at her brother, and she tenderly wiped his face clear of sweat. Then she kissed him on the nose and said, "That's okay. We like 'Good Alan,' 'Bad Alan,' any kind of Alan. As long as we get lots of Alan! Right, Aims?"
"Definitely!" She also turned to her side, extended her head forward and kissed him on the cheek.
Susan said to Suzanne, "Awww. Look at them. They're so cute. The only thing better than getting royally fucked by Tiger's jackhammer cock is when he gets all cuddly and tender afterwards. Don't you think?"
"Yeah." Suzanne said, all smiles. Susan and Suzanne were holding each other and looking at their children fondly, as if they were having some kind of Hallmark card moment like watching their child's first bicycle ride.
Susan added, "That's how he locks in the taming, you know. First, he fucks you within an inch of your life, leaving your body a helpless slave to his cock. But then, by being so cuddly and caring afterwards, he makes your heart and mind a slave to him too, and you can't help but love him more than you ever thought it was possible you could love another person. He leaves you wishing and longing that you could just suck his cock all day long!"
Suzanne was surprised to find that she agreed with all that, even the cocksucking part. She just repeated "Yeah" with a fond and wistful sigh.
Susan went on, "Just look at him. Surrounded on both sides by his busty fuckable sisters, lying there like the conquering hero, knowing full well that he just fucked every single big-titted member of his oh-so-fuckable family. And that's what he is: the conquering hero! First, he single-handedly defeats an entire gang of school hoodlums, and then he comes home and fucks his tamed family into an even deeper level of submission! And yet look how modest he is about it. He isn't beating his chest; he doesn't have to. I just wish there was some way I could do MORE to show how much I love him!"
Alan finally sat up so he could look at his mothers. "Hey, Mom. I'm here and listening to every word, you know. That's not really true. For one thing, I hardly single-handedly defeated Ryan's gang. It was Christine who kicked butt and I just barely hung in there."
"Well, maybe so," Susan said, "but I only have eyes for you. To me, you're the greatest hero." Her face lit up in a smile so bright that it practically filled the room with a happy glow. Then she noticed his messy crotch and got more practical. "By the way, girls, are you two just gonna lie there all day, or is someone going to do some tongue cleaning on Alan Junior?"
Alan covered his privates with his hand. "Thanks, but no thanks. I'm seriously sore down there."
There was a collective sigh from all four women. "Awwww..."
"What?" he asked.
Surprisingly, Amy was the one to explain, "Giving your cock a good tongue cleaning afterwards has become kind of a tradition. And traditions are fun, and good, and important, especially in a harem."
He was a bit curious to hear an explanation for her "especially in a harem" comment, but his penis really was sore, so he tried to change the topic. "What I could use is a shower and a re-bandaging." He held up the hand he'd been plunging into his sisters' pussies. Those bandages were wet with girl cum.
Susan started walking towards him, her big breasts jiggling and swaying with every step. "Awww. Tiger. Let Mommy take care of you. Come on, I'll give you a sponge bath."
But Suzanne said, "Um, actually, Susan, he has two mommies now. Can I do it this time?"
Susan was hesitant, but then smiled. "Sure."
Suzanne then struck a pose by raising both her arms above her head and asked Alan, "What do you think, kiddo? Is your second mommy Suzanne sexy enough to give you a sponge bath?"
Alan looked around in mock confusion. "Suzanne who? You're not her; you're Venus, the Goddess of Sex come to Earth."
Now Suzanne was the one beaming with delight.
Alan also grinned with great glee to see just how happy and excited Suzanne was to give him his bath. Her usual sophisticated jadedness was all gone and she was just like a big kid again.
Alan felt great after sexually satisfying his family, and felt even better than that after Suzanne gave him a sponge bath that was at times playful and sexy, and at times tender and loving. And she gave his penis and balls a good tongue cleaning while she was at it. His flaccid dick wasn't so sensitive anymore, and she half-jokingly pointed out that Susan would get mad if she didn't do it.
He thought, I know I say this to myself every day, usually several times a day, but I really have to be the luckiest guy in the whole country. I mean, Suzanne is so HOT! And funny and fun, too. She made that sponge bath such a blast, even though Alan Junior couldn't get hard. If only Mom knew how long I was sucking on Mother's big pale tits, she's be totally jealous. Heh! And yet Suzanne is only one of a bunch of centerfold-quality women in my harem. My harem! I have a fucking harem! That is so nuts!
But what's even more amazing is that they all love me, and I love them. The way they all were so concerned about me today, and did everything they could to help - my God! It brings tears to my eyes. That love is way more of a blessing than all their oh-so-fuckable bodies. What did I do to deserve this?
But after he went back to his bedroom to take his usual afternoon nap, he realized he still wasn't at peace. So he called downstairs for his mother to come up and join him in his room. He had to disabuse Susan of the notion that he wanted to have sex again, by telling her that he was having trouble relaxing and wanted to see if drinking her milk would help calm him down.
Susan was beside herself with happiness as she climbed into bed and lay alongside him where he could easily nurse from her milk-filled breasts. "I've been hoping you'd say something like that. My nipples hurt something awful 'cos I'm overdue for a milking. I've been saving all my milk just for you!"
He steadily drained her until her reservoirs of milk were depleted. The intimacy of nursing was enjoyable and calming for them both, but Alan found he still couldn't relax enough to fall asleep.
He felt sexually satiated and knew that he wouldn't be able to get it up again for a long while, but his body still felt antsy and agitated, so he was still in no mood for a nap. Also, now that he'd had some time to think, he found his thoughts were racing also.
After convincing his mother that "No, Alan Junior isn't ready to play again," he went with her to the living room, fully dressed, where the other women were lounging about in various states of undress (Amy, not surprisingly, was completely naked). He announced that he was going on a run to burn off more of his nervous energy. His body was tired and sore from the bruises, but he explained that it was something he needed to do.