Cherreads

Chapter 42 - Chapter 41: To Become After

The light pouring from Kamina's body condensed along the edge of the katana as he drove it forward straight into the center of the chest of Shmuel before him. Into the place where, underneath everything that grief and the City had built over it, a human being still lived.

The spiral energy that had no name in this world, the force born from the refusal to stop moving, the stubborn, reckless belief that tomorrow could be dragged into existence through sheer will, poured through the steel and into what remained of Shmuel like a current finding the sea.

The world went white.

The white of mineral dust hanging in dead air. The white of limestone walls worn smooth by generations of hands. The white of torch-lit passages going nowhere, leading only deeper, ending only when the rock decided it did not want to be moved.

Shmuel stood in it.

His hands were his own again. Both of them. He looked at his palms, at the ordinary human flesh of them, and felt the absence of the metal that had replaced them like a phantom limb in reverse.

He was underground.

He could feel it in his lungs. The closeness of it. The weight of everything above pressing down on the stillness below.

"Boring, right?"

Kamina stood beside him with his hands behind his head and his cape hanging loose, the posture of a man whose entire body had decided that urgency was someone else's problem.

"This is the Adai village's mining ground," he said. "Used to come here to goof off in the corner and sleep through the day. The guys from my village couldn't find me when I was here. Nobody bothered to look next door."

Shmuel looked at him.

"This is where you come from?"

"Nahh, I'm from next door. But close enough." Kamina shrugged. "Underground's underground. Stone's stone. Same ceiling, different patch of dirt."

He turned and pointed.

Down the passage, where the torchlight thinned and the dust hung thicker, a boy was working.

He was small. Smaller than Shmuel expected from anything Kamina had spoken about or gestured toward in the language of legacy. He wore a brown cloak, pulled up around his shoulders to shield against the mineral grit that the drilling threw outward in fine clouds. Brown shorts beneath. White socks gone gray with stone dust. Brown boots that had been resoled at least once and would need it again. White bandages wound around his abdomen. Around his neck, hanging on a cord, a small drill-shaped key that caught the torchlight when he moved.

The rock he was drilling was wrong for the tools he had. Wrong for the approach. Wrong in some fundamental geological way that suggested whoever had assigned him this particular section of passage had either made a clerical error or simply did not expect the task to be completed.

The boy drilled anyway.

When the drill skipped off the surface, he repositioned, read the angle, and went again. The quiet, methodical insistence of someone who had decided that this rock would move and had not yet received any information he considered sufficient to change that decision.

"Why is he drilling that," Shmuel said. "It's the wrong kind of stone for that bit."

"Yep."

"Then why."

Kamina didn't answer immediately. He watched the boy work with an expression Shmuel had not seen on him before. Something underneath all of that. Something that looked reverent.

"When I first watched him," Kamina said, "I thought the same thing. Kid's spinning his wheels. Hopeless. Impossible. Stone doesn't care how hard you try, it's just stone."

The boy's drill skipped again. He pulled back, turned the bit slightly, found a new point of contact.

"But look at him," Kamina said. "He's not trying to break it the way you'd break it. He's not trying to break it the way I'd break it. He's looking at the rock the way the rock actually is and figuring out the one exact angle it doesn't want him to find." A beat. "Slowly."

"He'll wear himself out before he reaches it."

"Watch."

Shmuel watched.

The boy shifted his weight. Repositioned one foot, then the other, until something in his stance settled into a geometry. He pressed the drill forward.

The rock broke.

A fracture along a fault line that had been invisible until the exact moment the boy's drill found the only point in the entire surface where the stone was, in fact, prepared to be moved.

Dust and fragments of grey stone scattered outward into the torchlight.

The passage opened.

Shmuel stood very still.

"That," Kamina said, "is where it comes from. The whole damn thing. Do the impossible. Kick logic to the curb." He dropped his hands from behind his head and crossed his arms, and the reverence in his expression shifted into something warmer and more reckless. "I believed in him to do what I couldn't do myself. And I led him loud enough that he stopped believing the world when it said he couldn't."

He glanced at Shmuel sideways.

"We did things after that. Things that don't have words in the language of this city you live in." A pause. "We pierced the heavens. Literally. Guy stole the ceiling of the sky and broke it open with a drill."

"What happened to him," Shmuel asked.

"I don't know his ending." Kamina said it simply, without grief and without deflection. "My ending happened first. But I had pushed him far enough by then that when he hit the wall of my absence, it didn't crush him. He carried it and kept going." His jaw set. "His name is Simon. Simon the Digger. And whatever he faced after me, I know he faced it head on because that's the only thing I ever taught him how to do."

The boy in the passage had not looked up. He was already surveying the new section of stone beyond the breach, the Core Drill turning slowly in his fingers as he mapped the work ahead.

Shmuel watched him.

"I'm not like him," he said finally. "I can't find the angle in the impossible rock. I looked at Bruno and I felt…" His voice went somewhere flat and careful. "I don't have what he has."

"Your hate for that new Bruno is wrong and you know it."

The word landed between them like something dropped from a height.

Shmuel did not answer.

"You know it," Kamina said again, without raising his voice. "That's the thing that's eating you."

"She will never be Bruno." Shmuel said. "She will never be her. She has the memory but she is not the continuity."

"Yeah."

"Then you understand…!"

"I understand you're scared."

Kamina turned to face him fully.

"You're terrified that if you let her be Bruno, you have to stop mourning the one who's gone. And if you stop mourning her, she's really gone. And if she's really gone…" He stopped.. "You don't know what you are without the weight of her."

"Kamina…"

"Call me Bro."

"I'm…"

"LET'S SEE HOW YOU GRIND THOSE TEETH."

The punch connected with Shmuel's face. He simply delivered the point through the most direct available medium.

"Ow!"

"You have kindness to show a stranger you met randomly in the backstreets," Kamina said, shaking out his hand with absolutely no remorse. "Me. You helped me when I had nothing on me and no reason yet to trust you. You did that because that's who you are."

Shmuel held his face. "That's because you saved me first…"

"Doesn't matter about that part." Kamina waved it away. "What matters is you looked at a person and decided they were worth the trouble before you had any proof. That's not weakness." He pointed at him. "That's the exact same quality Simon had when he was drilling rock in a dead-end passage because someone needed the tunnel to keep going."

Shmuel was quiet for a moment.

Down the passage, Simon had begun again.

"What do I do now, Kamin…"

"Bro."

A long pause.

"…What do I do now. Bro."

Kamina grinned.

"Talk to Bruno. Let her have her chance to clear your hate for her." He said. "She didn't ask to be built. She didn't ask to be rebuilt. The old Bruno poured something into body that wasn't finished yet." He tilted his head slightly. "That's not nothing, man."

"She will never be her," Shmuel said again. 

"No," Kamina agreed. "She won't."

He let that stand.

Then he walked past Shmuel, toward the passage and the figure at the end of it who was still drilling, still working, still committed to the specific section of stone that the world had decided was impossible.

He did not look back.

"Man up," he said. "You're going to need it."

The mining passage fading slowly, the breath fogs a cold window and then clears.

The stone walls thinned. The torchlight bled away. The sound of Simon's drill faded last, its rhythm holding a moment longer than everything else before that too went quiet.

Shmuel stood on the forward deck of the Titanic.

The black sea stretched in every direction. Cold wind moved across the deck in long, slow passes.

Bruno stood at the very bow.

Both hands on the railing. Her back to him. Her brown hair moved in the wind and she did not turn when his footsteps crossed the deck toward her.

He stopped a few feet away.

Neither of them spoke for a moment.

"Am I her?" Bruno asked.

"No."

"Figured." She said it without bitterness. "Within an hour and a half of existing, all the recycled memory settled into me. It became mine. Including what happened between you and her."

Shmuel was quiet.

"Everything," she said. "Even the things she never said to you."

"Then you know what she felt."

"I know what she remembered feeling. Whether I feel it…" She paused. "I don't know yet. I've been awake for ninety minutes."

He looked at the side of her face. The profile was exact. The way she held the railing, thumbs hooked slightly inward that was exact too. Details assembled from something the original had pressed into the biology of a body that wasn't finished being built.

"What is the point," he said, "of your existence."

Bruno turned her head slightly.

"Would any answer I give matter?"

"No."

"Then I don't have one." She turned back to the sea. "I've been asking it myself since the tank broke. I don't think the answer is in me yet. Maybe it never will be."

"Would killing you be what I want right now?"

"I don't know," she said. "Would it?"

Shmuel's hands curled at his sides. He stood there with the wind pulling at his coat and the distant iceberg sitting at the edge of the world like a verdict, and he did not move.

"I looked at you in that tank," he said finally. "Before you were… before you had a face. And I hated what I saw. I hated that something had been built in her place and called by her name." He stopped. "I still hate it."

"I know."

"I don't know how to look at you and not see everything that was taken."

Bruno was quiet for a long moment.

Then she stepped back from the railing and turned to face him fully.

Her blue eyes were the same shade. That was the worst part. The original had looked at him with those eyes and memorized the way he angled his head when he was refusing to admit something hurt, and that memory was now behind different eyes looking at him with the same knowledge.

"She hated that she loved you because she couldn't return it," Bruno said. "She hated the shape love took in her. Hidden in the margins of ordinary moments."

Shmuel said nothing.

Bruno said. "She didn't have enough time to find that out."

"Stop."

"I'm not her. I know that. But I have everything she knew and the first thing I used it for was to break a tank and punch your distortion across a laboratory." A pause. "I think she would have found that funny."

He walked to the railing and stood beside her, not looking at her. Looking at the sea.

"When I became that thing," he said. "The voice told me to scuttle the ship. End the paradox. I almost did."

"I know. I was in the tank when you raised the water cannon."

"What stopped you from staying in the tank."

Bruno considered this.

"Nothing stopped me. I chose to come out." She rested her hands on the railing again, close to his but not touching. "I don't know if that was the old Bruno's muscle memory or something I decided myself. I'm not sure if the distinction means anything yet."

"It means everything," Shmuel said.

"Does it?" She looked at him. "You walked through a room with a spear through your chest. Was that the Shmuel before tonight or a new one?"

He had no answer.

The wind moved between them.

"I am not a replacement," Bruno said. "I'm not a continuation either. I don't have a clean word for what I am." She looked out at the water. "The old Bruno loved you and poured it into the only thing she had left, the heartbeat she was losing. I woke up carrying that. I didn't ask for it. I don't know what to do with it. But I'm not going to pretend it isn't there just because it makes the question of my identity more complicated."

"You're using her feelings as your own."

"They are my own now. That's the Ship's problem and neither of us is going to solve it tonight." She glanced at him. "You know that."

Shmuel's jaw tightened.

"I know," he said.

"Walk with me," Bruno said.

It wasn't a request exactly.

Shmuel looked at her for a moment.

Then he pushed off the railing and walked beside her.

They moved along the deck without destination. The iron humanoids they passed had stilled, standing in their frozen poses, their corroded hands on windows, their hollow postures carrying some approximation of longing that no longer looked threatening. Just sad. The Abnormality's passengers, going nowhere, stopped in permanent suspension between departure and a port they would never reach.

"She beat you at chess," Bruno said.

"Every time except the last."

"She let you win the last one."

Shmuel stopped walking.

"She thought you needed it more than she needed the win." Bruno kept moving and he caught up after a step. "She was right. You were exhausted and she could see it and she calculated that a clean loss would make her less worried about you for one night."

"She never told me that."

"She never told you a lot of things." Bruno's voice was even. "She was afraid that saying them out loud would change the shape of what you had. That naming it would make it too heavy to carry quietly." A beat. "She preferred to carry things quietly."

"She was stubborn."

"Extraordinarily."

They reached the stern. The ship was longer from the inside of the Abnormality than any physics should allow, the deck stretched and contracted with the internal logic of a grief that had no interest in consistent scale. They stood at the rear rail and looked back at the wake that didn't exist, the flat black sea undisturbed behind them.

"I will never be her," Bruno said. "I want to be honest with you about that. A fact we should both be standing on."

"I know."

"And the hate you have for me…"

"Is real," Shmuel said. "I'm not going to tell you it isn't."

"I'm not asking you to."

He looked at her.

"I hate that you have her face," he said. "I hate that you carry her memory and I can't tell where the boundary is. I hate what it cost and I hate that the cost produced something I don't know how to categorize."

Bruno listened without looking away.

"And I hate," he said, "that she poured her love into a body she was losing and trusted it to reach you, and it did. And that is the most specifically terrible thing I can imagine, because it means she planned this moment. She anticipated standing here and she chose to give you that and she's not here to know if it worked."

The wind was very quiet.

"It worked," Bruno said.

"I know. That makes it worse."

She turned from the rail and faced him, her back to the sea now, and for the first time since he'd crossed the deck toward her, something in her expression shifted from careful to something less managed.

"I'm not asking you to love me," she said. "I'm not asking you to stop hating this. I know what I am. I know it's wrong and strange and unresolved and I will be unresolved for a very long time." She held his gaze. "But I am here. And the heart she left in this body is hammering every time you're close to me and I cannot pretend I don't feel it."

Shmuel looked at her for a long time.

Then he turned back to face the sea and she turned with him, and they stood together at the rear of the impossible ship with the iceberg somewhere far ahead and the black water everywhere else, and the hour they had was running and neither of them moved to waste it.

"Tell me something she never told me," he said finally.

Bruno thought about it.

"She was going to challenge you to a proper tournament match," she said. "She'd been studying the Ruy Lopez opening specifically to beat you with it. She had the whole line memorized." A pause. "She never got to use it."

Shmuel was silent for a moment.

"She would have won."

"Yes," Bruno said. "She would have."

Shmuel raised his hand.

Palm forward then fingers spread.

The iceberg moved.

It did not drift or accelerate gradually. It came with the entire mass of it, the visible peak and the vast cathedral of ice beneath the waterline, moving across the black sea with the silent speed of something that had always been heading here and had only been waiting for permission.

Bruno looked at it.

"You're going to sink it."

"We're going to sink it," Shmuel said. "This is my Abnormality. My grief built it. I'll end it with the help of Kamina."

She looked at him once. Then she turned and faced the oncoming mass beside him.

The shadow reached them first.

The temperature dropped before the impact, a cold so sudden. The light changed. The stars above went white with the reflected mass of ice rising over the bow.

Then the Titanic met the iceberg.

A long, grinding scream of steel being persuaded against its body, a sound that started below the waterline and travelled upward through every rivet and plate and timber in the ship's body. The deck lurched.

From somewhere deep below, a series of compartments began accepting the sea.

The bow sank first, slowly, the forward railing descending toward the waterline. Furniture shifted belowdecks. The iron humanoids tilted in their frozen poses, some toppling, some remaining upright at new and wrong angles, their hollow gestures of longing preserved even as the floor dropped beneath them.

The stern began to rise.

Shmuel and Bruno moved aft with the tilt of the deck, their feet finding purchase on the angled wood. Around them the ship was becoming a different geometry, the grand staircase behind the sealed doors filled with water that found its own level regardless of what the architecture expected of it. The glass dome above the foyer fractured as pressure shifted, sending fragments of refracted light across surfaces that were now wrong-side-up.

The stern climbed higher, the propellers lifting clear of the water. Shmuel and Bruno moved upward with it, hands finding railings and cables and whatever the ship offered, climbing toward the highest point as the bow sank beneath them.

Below, the sea accepted everything it was given without comment.

The hull groaned from within. 

The Titanic had always been, in the end, a thing built to float and not to fall. It had never been designed for this particular use of itself.

The break happened amidships.

A crack that ran from the waterline upward, irregular, following the weakest seams, splitting the ship across its middle with a sound like a sentence being interrupted. The bow section tore free and slid beneath the surface, taking its half of the deck and its frozen passengers.

The stern section stood vertical for a moment.

Completely vertical, the remaining half of the ship pointing straight up at the stars, the propellers highest, the railings beneath Shmuel and Bruno the only thing between them and the sea far below.

"Now," Shmuel said.

The stern fell.

The cold hit Bruno before the water did.

Then the water hit everything.

The sea closed over her.

The deck had vanished. The ship had vanished. There was only the dark water and the sound of debris settling around her and the distant, fading structural groans of the Titanic completing its sinking somewhere below.

She did not panic.

Found upward. Began to move.

Something grabbed her wrist.

Shmuel pulled her to the surface.

They broke through together and gasped, the cold air worse in its way than the water had been and around them the debris field spread across the black sea. Planking. Sections of railing. A dining chair floating with perfect composure. The wreckage of something vast and personal, reduced at last to components.

Bruno looked at the surface of the water.

At all the pieces.

"It's done," she said.

"It's done," Shmuel said.

He was still holding her wrist.

He did not immediately let go.

The black sea around them began to thin. The water lightened from below. The stars overhead lost their too-many quality and reduced themselves to something honest. The cold persisted but changed character, from the cold of an impossible ocean to the cold of a real facility floor and water from ruptured reservoirs and the aftermath of a fight that had cost everyone something they wouldn't finish counting until much later.

Shmuel released her wrist.

"When we go back," he said.

Bruno looked at him.

"Could we pretend we never met each other."

The debris moved slowly around them on the fading water.

"For the rest of our lives," he said. "I'm asking you. That we never…" He stopped. Reorganized. "I know what you are. I know what she left in you. I can't carry that and also function. So I'm asking if we could simply-"

"My heart," Bruno said, "will not let me forget it."

She pressed her hand once to her sternum, the place where the fractured glass heart had floated in the flooded dining hall, the place where the old Bruno had compressed every remaining thread of will into a rhythm that was meant to recognize him.

"It hammers when you're near me. She built it to. I don't have the ability to override it and I'm not sure I would if I could." Her hand dropped. "I will not pursue you. I will not ask for anything. But I cannot promise you something my own body won't honor."

Shmuel looked at her for a long moment.

The water around them was nearly gone now. The pieces of the Titanic were dissolving at the edges, losing definition, returning to the grief they had been constructed from. Below them the floor of the Izan facility was becoming real again, wet concrete, broken machinery, the cooling water from ruptured reservoirs spreading across the chamber in shallow pools.

The Abnormality was ending.

Bruno held his gaze until the last moment.

"I'll stay out of your way," she said. "That much I can do."

The ocean finished disappearing.

They were standing in the laboratory.

The grinder was destroyed. The monitors were shattered. The tank that had held Bruno was open and empty, its mechanisms dead. Around them the walls were cracked and the ceiling had partially given way and the floor held four inches of cold brine that reflected the emergency lighting in dull, steady pulses.

Kamina's voice came from somewhere above them, still carrying that particular quality of someone who had just done something absurd and was very pleased about it.

Shmuel stood in the real world.

He looked at his hands.

Both of them. His own. The metal of the distortion was gone, or receding, or filing itself away into whatever part of him it now permanently occupied. He flexed his fingers and felt the familiar resistance of the mechanical arm alongside the organic one.

He breathed.

Behind him, Bruno stood barefoot on the wet concrete in the ruins of the place that had built her, and said nothing, and the heartbeat in her chest kept its own counsel.

Shmuel heard the slap before he felt it.

"Welcome back, Bro."

He stumbled one step forward and turned. Kamina stood behind him with his hands on his hips and smiling his ass off.

Imogen was beside him. Her E.G.O. was fully withdrawn, her mechanical eye back to its pale resting color, her coat scorched at both cuffs. She looked at Shmuel with the particular exhaustion of someone who had used up everything they had and was now running on principle alone.

"So that's how it feels," she said, "dealing with a distortion."

"You were one," Shmuel said.

"Which is exactly why I would prefer to never fight another one again." She crossed her arms. "But this time it's your fault, Shmuel."

"It's refreshing," he said, "to be back."

He looked back at Bruno.

Fifty Izan enforcers filed into the chamber through every available entrance simultaneously. They fanned outward along the walls, weapons drawn, filling the room with silence.

Franz walked in behind them.

He surveyed the laboratory.

Kamina looked at all of them.

He was standing with his katana sheathed and both arms hanging at his sides and every muscle in his body at the absolute limit of what a human body could be asked to produce. He and Imogen had fought for the better part of five hours. They had nothing left. No reserves, no second wind, nothing that could be converted into another exchange.

"You have got to be," Kamina said, "the single most persistent pain in the ass of an organization I have ever had the displeasure of conducting business with."

He looked at the fifty enforcers with genuine irritation.

Franz did not respond to this.

He reached up and removed his hat.

From inside it he produced an envelope.

He held it for a moment with the expression of someone who found the gesture as unusual as everyone else in the room did, then crossed the flooded floor to Bruno and held it out.

Bruno took it.

The wax seal bore the mark of the Fury. She broke it, unfolded the paper inside, and read it without expression. The room stayed quiet. The enforcers did not move. Even Kamina, who had approximately no natural tolerance for silence, waited.

Bruno folded the letter.

"The Fury," Franz announced, "along with Team One and Team Two of the Izan, has been booked in the Library."

"The will instructs," he continued, "that upon successful completion of the Successor's recycle cycle, the head of the Izan passes to the new Queen Piece." He looked at Bruno. "The recycle succeeded."

Bruno stood with the folded letter in her hand for a moment. Then she slipped it into the pocket of the plain clothes that had been assembled onto her at some point during the maturation process, the bare minimum gesture toward the formality of what she had just been handed.

"The Great Kamina Office," she said, addressing Franz directly, "is not to be harmed. That order stands effective immediately and does not expire."

Franz's expression did not change. "Understood. However, their raid resulted in considerable casualties among our enforcer ranks and the disruption of the VIP event above resulted in…"

"I didn't ask for a ledger," Bruno said.

"Yes," Franz said. "Ma'am."

Bruno turned slightly and looked at Shmuel.

"If we had met from the start as what we are," she said, "it would have been easier for both of us. A syndicate boss and a fixer. A Legible relationship." A beat. "It would have been easier."

"Yes," Shmuel said.

Bruno turned to Kamina.

"Report this raid to the Hana Association as your office's victory," she said. "The dismantling of Izan's combat infrastructure, Team One, Team Two, the Fury's leadership report it as yours. The achievement is your office's to claim."

Kamina looked at her.

"That's your organization's achievement."

"No," Bruno said. "But the Hana Association doesn't know that."

"Then we will take our leave."

Kamina turned toward the exit and started walking, stepping over debris and through the shallow water on the floor.

Imogen followed.

Shmuel walked with them.

At the threshold he stopped.

Looking back across the ruined laboratory.

Bruno stood in the center of it. The fifty enforcers around the walls. Franz beside her. The new head of the Izan, barefoot on wet concrete, holding a dead man's letter.

She was already looking at him.

"Until we can resolve our feeling," Shmuel said, "I hate you for the rest of my life."

Bruno held his gaze.

"Until we can resolve our feeling," she said, "I will love you until my heart gets ripped out of my body."

Shmuel turned and walked out.

More Chapters