"Authenticity in argument," I say slowly, "assumes there's a clear line between performance and truth. But what if that line doesn't exist?"
"Elaborate."
"We're always performing. Even when we think we're being authentic, we're making choices about how to present ourselves. What words to use. What tone to take. What vulnerabilities to reveal."
"So you're arguing authenticity is impossible?"
"I'm arguing it's more complicated than true versus false. Maybe authenticity is about being conscious of the performance. Owning it."
He moves closer to the front row. Eyes locked on mine.
"That's a convenient position for someone who makes a living performing online."
A few students shift uncomfortably. The comment has an edge.
