Cherreads

Chapter 2 - Episode 102: The Interrogation of Sin

Heat: Scorching

Content Warnings: BDSM, Bondage, Implied Consent

Director's note: Episode two raises the temperature and tests the limits of trust. This chapter marks Thomas's true initiation aboard the Silent Tide, where desire, dominance, and ritual blur into a single act of transformation. What begins as fear becomes faith. What feels like surrender becomes belonging. Every motion here burns for a reason, and every scar earns its meaning.

Chapter Three

The rough threads of the mooring line burned against Thomas's palms as he hauled himself up. Sounds of cheers, moans, and groans from the Silent Tide above masked his clumsy scrambling. The salt-stung air was thick with the smells of cheap rum, roasted meat, and the honest sweat of a crew celebrating another day of dodging death. He dropped over the gunwale, landing with a soft thud on the deck, his heart drumming a frantic rhythm against his ribs. He'd been overlooked by their crew that afternoon. Tonight, he'd find a way to make a compelling case to stay. He hoped his daring midnight venture across the bay would reinforce his seriousness. 

The scene was a living, breathing debauchery. In the flickering torchlight, men roared with laughter, their hands roaming over women whose painted smiles didn't quite reach their eyes. It was a raw, unvarnished transaction of flesh and coin. But his gaze, snagged and held, was drawn to the stern.

There, in a high-backed chair carved from some dark, foreign wood, sat the Captain. Shadows clung to the figure like a second skin, obscuring all but a booted foot propped on a crate and the glint of a silver ring on a long-fingered hand. The Captain observed the carnal festival with an unnerving stillness, a silent monarch presiding over a court of hedonism. A sharp, gestured command from the gloom sent a brutish mate scurrying. The voice that followed was a low, graveled thing, its pitch ambiguous, its authority absolute. Thomas couldn't look away.

A meaty hand clamped down on his shoulder, spinning him around. A rugged man's face, a roadmap of old scars and newer rage, loomed inches from his own. Rum-soured breath washed over him. "Spyin' on your betters, lad?"

Before Thomas could form a denial, he was being dragged, his heels scraping against the deck planks, toward the shadowed throne. The Captain didn't move, didn't speak. A single, dismissive wave of that ring-adorned hand was their only verdict. The weathered man grunted, shoving Thomas toward a heavy door.

The Captain's quarters were a world apart. The reek of the crew was replaced by the scent of beeswax, old leather, and a faint, exotic spice. A single oil lamp guttered on a massive desk, its light failing to reach the corners of the room. The door shut with a solid, final thump, sealing him in. The Captain remained by the door, a silhouette against the carved wood.

As Thomas' eyes adjusted, he discovered the strong woman from earlier mending a sail in the corner. She set her work aside without a word and moved into the lamplight. Her large frame was undeniable. It was the first mate he had seen earlier. She was… formidable. Hair the color of dark honey was braided tightly against her scalp. Her eyes, a shade of golden brown, assessed him with a terrifying clinical dispassion. She wore practical trousers and a loose tunic, but the way she moved screamed of a feral, contained power.

She didn't speak. She simply approached, her steps silent on the rug. Her fingers, calloused and strong, went to the laces of his shirt. He flinched back. Her grip on his wrist was instant, iron-strong, yanking him forward. There'd be no negotiations here. The message was clear, delivered through touch alone. His shirt was pulled open, then off, the cool air raising goosebumps on his skin. He didn't feel cold. The adrenaline pumping through his veins in fiery chaos.

Her touch was not gentle. It was a thorough inspection. Her palms scraped over his chest, her thumbs pressing into the muscle of his arms, evaluating his soft merchant's body with a humiliating efficiency. 

"I have to search you." She paused to look into his eyes. Her voice offered an unexpected sense of compassion. This was a choice, even though the alternative was likely very unpleasant. He nodded yes to her.

A hot flush of shame warred with a traitorous spark of desire as her hand slipped down, dancing down his thigh. She made a noncommittal sound in her throat, then pushed him backward until his legs hit the edge of the large desk.

She unbuckled his belt with swift, practiced movements, yanking his trousers and smallclothes down to his knees in one motion. The cool air was a shock against his bare skin. Freed from his clothing, he felt an uncontrollable growing excitement. 

She looked down, a smirk curling her lips. "Merchant boy, you do know you're in danger right? Do you find this exciting?"

Thomas's shy eyes hardly met hers. "It does appear that way"

A devious thought bounced around her eyes before she produced a small vial from a pocket, coating her fingers with a slick, floral-scented oil. "Riley."

He looked down at her soft gaze, "Thomas". They held eyes for a moment, a pact that this interrogation was about to take an unexpected turn.

Her hand closed around him. Thomas jolted, a gasp tearing from his throat. Her technique was unholy. It was too much, too good, a direct assault on his senses. He threw his head back, a groan escaping him as pleasure.

Through the haze, a new sound filtered in. A soft, rhythmic creak of leather. He had forgotten they were not alone. He forced his eyes open, looking toward the Captain.

The shadowed figure had finally moved. They had unbuckled their own trousers, freeing themselves. The Captain's silver ring glinted in the dark, a spectator to his unraveling, and finding their own pleasure in the display.

Riley's other hand snaked around his hip, her nails digging crescents into his buttock, holding him in place as her ministrations became more intense, more focused. She's not going to let me finish. The realization hit him like a bucket of cold water. This was a demonstration. A prelude. A way to soften him up, to make him pliable.

His mind raced even as his hips began to move against his will. He did not find men attractive. The thought of what that shadowed figure, that male Captain, might expect from him next twisted his stomach into a cold knot. His lack of participation, his rejection, would mean a swift and anonymous death in the dark sea. The pleasure coursing through him became tainted with a sharp, metallic fear.

He was trapped between Riley's devastating expertise and the Captain's terrifying, unknown intentions. He was balancing on a razor's edge, sensation and dread warring within him.

And then, from the darkness, it came. A soft, shuddering sigh. A moan. But it was all wrong. The pitch was wrong. It was too high, too melodic. It was not a man's sound at all.

It was unmistakably, undeniably, a woman's voice.

Chapter 4

The silence that followed her sigh was heavier than any threat. A woman. The thought cut through Thomas's fear, a clean, sharp slice that left him dizzy. The figure in the shadows was a woman. The power, the command, the terrifying authority; it was all feminine. His mind scrambled to reconfigure the world.

Before he could form a single coherent question, the woman astride him moved. Riley's playful dominance vanished, replaced by a swift, brutal efficiency. Her knee drove into his stomach, not enough to truly hurt, but enough to steal the air from his lungs and pin him flat to the rough planks. He gasped, his head spinning. With the Captain's gender revealed, precautions had to be taken.

"Stay," Riley commanded, her voice a low thrum of amusement. Her hands, shockingly fast, produced two lengths of coarse rope from a hook on the wall. She looped them around his wrists with the practiced ease of a sailor tying a cleat hitch, yanking them taut and securing them to a heavy iron ring bolted to the floor. He was trussed, spread-eagle and utterly vulnerable. Married to the ship, he thought wildly.

She leaned over him, her dark hair a curtain blocking out the lantern light. Her scent, salt and jasmine, filled his nostrils. From a sheath at her hip, she drew not a knife, but a long, oil-dark strap of leather. She held it before his eyes, letting him see its worn surface, then drew it down his body. It whispered over his chest, his abdomen, a threatening caress. The sensation was a paradox; the smooth, teasing drag of the hide and the implicit promise of a stinging blow. It was pleasure and a warning, intertwined.

Riley leaned close, her lips brushing his ear. "The Captain enjoys a show. Be the show." For the first time since this whirlpool began he thought of Nadine. Their paths had aligned paradoxically. What would she think of this pursuit? 

Riley sensed his drifting thoughts and grabbed his cheek. With that, she descended. Her mouth was now a weapon of pure sensation. It wasn't like before. This was not a seduction but rather a preparation. Riley dutifully prepped Thomas with a relentless, focused rhythm, her sole purpose to make him more. And it was for her. For the Captain.

Just as he felt the unbearable tension coiling at the base of his spine, she stopped, pulling away gently. She left him desperate on the edge, a tool readied for its purpose. She rose and moved back into the shadows near the great desk. Thomas strained against his bonds, trying to see.

He heard the soft rustle of clothing, the quiet clink of a belt buckle, and a low, approving hum from the woman. The same mouth that had just been on him was now lavishing attention on the Captain. The air grew thick with the scent of a musky-sweet perfume.

Then, she emerged.

The Captain stepped into the flickering lantern light, and the breath caught in Thomas's chest. She was… a vision of war and want. Her body was a map of conquest, both given and received. Slim, taut muscle corded her arms and defined her flat stomach. Small, perfect b***ts stood proud, their tips peaked and dark in the cool air. But it was the history etched into her skin that held him rapt. A faded blue tattoo coiled around her hip alongside a stark, jagged scar cutting a white line across her ribs. She was fit, naked, and utterly unashamed.

Her eyes, now visible, were a startling pale grey, like winter mist over the sea. They held his, not with warmth, but with an appraising, hungry intensity. She was assessing her property. Her hands slid down her own body and a faint, throaty sound of approval escaped her. She was more than ready.

She moved to him with the rolling gait of a predator, her bare feet silent on the wood. She placed a knee on either side of his hips, looming over him, a goddess of the deep. Riley moved behind her, a graceful shadow, and cupped the Captain. The Captain gave a soft sigh hissing through her teeth.

Without a word, without breaking eye contact with Thomas, she reached down between them. The heat of her was astounding. A velvety, impossible heat that seemed to pull at him. Then she sank down.

It was a slow, inexorable claiming. A sharp gasp escaped him, his fingers curling into useless fists against the ropes. She was alive.

Her eyes remained locked on his, watching his every flinch, every swallowed gasp, every helpless tug against the ropes. This wasn't his pleasure. It was hers. He was an instrument, and she was playing a symphony upon him.The Captain's breathing grew ragged, her movements becoming more urgent, more demanding. 

Thomas was lost. His fear was a distant memory, burned away by the furnace of her body. He could only watch, captive, as her control began to fracture. Her perfect posture began to falter. Her head tipped back, her throat a pale arc in the lamplight. Her lips parted. The low, guttural sounds she made were not of command, but of pure, unvarnished need.

Her entire body tensed, a bowstring pulled taut. A shudder wracked her frame, violent and absolute. She cried out a raw sound of triumph that was nothing like the soft moan from the shadows. It was the full, unabashed release of a queen taking her due.

She collapsed forward, her hands splayed on his chest, her body trembling with the aftershocks. Her breath was hot and rapid against his skin. For a long moment, there was only the sound of her breathing and the relentless, dull ache of his own unsated need.

Slowly, she pushed herself up, her grey eyes meeting his. They were dark now, sated, but still sharp. A faint, ruthless smile touched her lips.

"Adequate," she breathed, her voice husky for her small frame.

Chapter 5

Her weight left him, the cool air settling against his damp skin. She stood beside the berth, a silhouette of coiled authority against the lantern light. "I have many questions for you," the Captain stated, her voice low and even. "If you want to stay, you will answer my questions."

She looked over to Riley who welcomed the captain's authoritative voice. She smirked with a mischievous plan.

"And you will pleasure my first mate, Riley, willingly."

Thomas's throat was dry. He gave a single, sharp nod.

The Captain's eyes narrowed. Riley eased downward, and his world became breath, pressure, and the Captain's quiet approval.

"First question," the Captain said, her thumbs making small, possessive circles on his skin. "Who are you, and what do you want on my ship?"

In a flash, the heat of the Moon Gem came rushing back to him. He hoped this recollection had not exposed him. Thomas's mind scrambled. "I… I seek my fortune," he breathed out, the words feeling hollow even to him. "I want success."

The Captain's eyes, those piercing grey pools, narrowed. In an instant, Riley lowered herself. The air vanished, replaced overwhelmingly by her. He could feel the firm muscles of her thighs framing his ears. It was all rather metaphorical, this sexual beratement of his answer. Yet, he had seen women smaller than her crack watermelons in two, so he would be careful not to give too many lacking answers.

"To live amongst us means to surrender yourself completely. No merchant's lies. Now, what do you really want?" The Captain grabbed him with deliberate pressure.

The truth, raw and unfiltered, tore from him. "To feel it! The rush of life! To take what's mine!"

This time, Riley's descent was not a punishment but a reward. Her pleasure was palpable, a hungry, living thing. The Captain rewarded him in kind. Her hand wrapped around his aching length. The sensation was exquisitely smooth, almost unbearably good.

"Better," the Captain purred, her voice a low thrum he felt in his bones. "But to be with us means to trust us fully. A trust that is given, and earned. Do you trust me, Thomas?"

His answer was not with words this time. He buried his face deeper into Riley. Riley jolted, a high, surprised cry of pleasure escaping her. 

"We have to trust you, too, Thomas," the Captain murmured, her voice shifting as she moved, a shadow detaching itself from the edge of the berth. Riley was lost to it now, one hand braced on the wall. Her moans were muffled by the wood, her enjoyment of his service utterly genuine.

Then he felt it. A tug at his wrist. The rough hemp binding gave way. Then the other. His hands were free, the blood rushing back into his fingers with a prickling surge.

The Captain's form leaned over him, her lips close to his ear. Her whisper was the most intimate touch yet. "Can we trust you? Tell me. What are you truly willing to sacrifice for this life?"

His answer was immediate, physical, final. His newly freed hands came up, his palms finding the firm swell of Riley's buttocks. He held his breath, giving his full attention to her body. A guttural sound of pure approval vibrated through Riley's body. He was no longer a captive, but a participant, capitalizing on his freedom, and he would show them exactly what he was willing to do.

A low, possessive growl rumbled from the Captain's throat. "We share everything here." Her hand fisted in Riley's sun-streaked hair, yanking her head back to expose the elegant line of her neck. She fastened her mouth there, not a gentle kiss but a claiming, sucking at the skin until a faint bloom of red began to form beneath Riley's tan.

Riley's rhythm on Thomas stuttered, a choked groan of pure ecstasy escaping her as she dove into the Captain's mouth, her own pleasure amplified by the dual sensations. Thomas could only watch, mesmerized, as the Captain dominated her first mate as Riley dominated him. 

Just as Riley's movements became frantic, the Captain hauled her backward. Even at half her size, the Captain tossed Riley's weight onto the nearby heavy oak desk. Charts and a compass clattered to the floor, forgotten. The Captain couldn't resist her taste either. She dipped her head between Riley's thighs. Riley's back bowed off the desk, a raw, wordless cry ripped from her lungs as her release crashed over her.

The Captain looked over at Thomas, still lying on the floor, his chest heaving, his body humming with unmet need. A low, dark chuckle escaped her.

"You did a good job. She liked it."

The approval, so simple and direct, struck him harder than any blow. Riley, spent and smiling lazily, caught his eye and gave a slow, sleepy blink, her gaze then drifting meaningfully back toward the Captain, who was already returning to her feast.

And Thomas saw it. The situation presented itself with dizzying clarity. The Captain was bent over the edge of the desk, her body offered to him as she attended to Riley. Her skin shone with a fine sheen of sweat, and the sight of her, this formidable leader, laid bare and glistening for him, stole the air from his lungs. An invitation.

Tentative, his hand shaking slightly, he pushed himself up and stepped behind her. The heat radiating from her was immense. He placed a hand on the small of her back, feeling the corded muscle there. He didn't enter, not yet. 

A sharp, impatient noise came from the Captain, her voice muffled against Riley's thigh. Even lost in pleasure, a thread of command wove through her annoyance. "Take what's yours... Live!"

The words were a spark to tinder. It was a gift. She wasn't just giving him her body; she was offering him the key to the life he'd gambled everything for. Her. Permission. Belonging. His hesitation evaporated, burned away by a sudden, fierce certainty.

He pushed forward, a choked gasp was torn from the Captain. On the desk, Riley moaned in shared sensation, her eyes fluttering open to watch him. She was on a wave of ecstasy and another peak was around the corner.

They were connected, a circuit of pleasure. Each forward thrust pushed her body more firmly against Riley, a chain reaction of motion and sensation. He found a rhythm, a rolling wave of momentum where every inward plunge for him was an added pressure for them.

He lost himself in the feeling, in the symphony of their ragged breathing. The lantern light caught a mark on the Captain's shoulder he hadn't seen before: a crude, scarred 'A' carved into her skin. A life that had seen true death. This body was a map of a brutal, full existence, and he was now a part of its story.

A blissful shout from Riley snapped him from his thoughts. It was a sound of pure, unadulterated lust that seemed to circle the room and tighten around them all. She wrapped her strong thighs around the Captain's head, locking her in place. He couldn't hold back. They couldn't hold back.

Riley was the first to break. A raw, guttural scream was torn from her as she peaked. Her fingers dug into the Captain's back, her other hand shooting out to grip Thomas's forearm with startling force, her nails biting into his skin. The Captain, feeling Riley's pleasure so intimately, gave herself over completely. It was a perfect, harmonic convergence. Thomas's vision whited out as the energy surged through him, a scalding rush of intensity more powerful than anything he had ever known.

For a long moment, there was only the sound of their harsh, ragged breaths. The Captain slowly crawled up Riley's body, the two women meeting in a slow, deep kiss that tasted of shared exertion and satisfaction. 

Riley sat up on the desk, her eyes heavy-lidded and sated. The Captain turned her head, looking at him over her shoulder. Her grey eyes were dark, satisfied, but held a glint of something final. A curt, knowing smile touched her lips.

"Welcome to the pirate life, Thomas. We just have one last thing to do."

Chapter 6

The polished wood of the Captain's desk was firm but still warm from Riley's heat. Thomas lay back, his body still humming from their shared exertion, a pleasant soreness settling into his muscles. The two women moved around him with a practiced, predatory grace. Riley's fingers, calloused from rope and rigging, expertly looped a length of coarse hemp around his wrists, pulling the knot taut.

He tested the bond. It was firm, unyielding. A flicker of unease stirred in his gut.

"This is for your own good, I promise." The Captain's voice was a low, soothing murmur from somewhere in the room's periphery, a stark contrast to the commanding tone she'd used moments before. It did little to calm the sudden, racing beat of his heart.

His eyes scanned the dim cabin, chasing her shadow. A small bottle gleamed, no doubt some special concoction to prevent his seed from seeding. Then something else. A glint of firelight caught on metal in the darkness near the great mahogany wardrobe. Something sharp. Something meant to cut. Or to carve.

His body recoiled instinctively, his shoulders pressing into the desk. The heady, sated warmth that had filled him evaporated, replaced by a cold dread that tightened his throat. Had it all been a cruel game? Was he just a plaything, to be used for their amusement and then discarded over the rail like so much garbage? The thought was a physical blow, and he sank into the wood beneath him, the weight of his naivety crushing.

A chuckle, soft and deeply amused, echoed from the shadows. Riley ran her hand through his sweaty hair. "Relax, we're not going to kill you, Thomas."

From the shadows the Captain stepped into the circle of lantern light, the object in her hand now clearly visible: a long, slender branding iron, its tip cooled to a dull grey. Her grin was a slash of white in the cabin's gloom. She moved closer, the iron held loosely at her side. "But if you're going to stay, you have to do this. Understand that with every pleasure you take from this world, there is always a cost. This… is yours."

Before he could form a question, Riley stepped in front of him. She turned her back, presenting the powerful, sun-kissed canvas of her shoulders and back to him. And there it was, the same "A" that the Captain bore. A mark he hadn't noticed in the frenzied intimacy before. A scar, old and silvery, stamped into the flesh of her left shoulder blade. It wasn't a random design; it was a symbol, a simple letter that carried great meaning. A mark of ownership, of belonging. She looked at him over her shoulder, her expression not one of shame, but of fierce, unadulterated pride.

"Are you ready?" the Captain asked, her voice dropping to a whisper that was both a question and a command.

Thomas's eyes darted from Riley to the calculated, assessing gaze of the Captain. His fear didn't vanish, but it was suddenly dwarfed by something greater, something that had driven him to this ship in the first place: a desperate, clawing need to belong. To be part of something real, something wild and true. "Let's do this." Thomas released a decision made in the space between one heartbeat and the next. He embraced the thought of the pain, accepted it as the price of the pleasure, the key to the life he craved.

The two women moved to either side of the desk. Riley's strong hands came down on his free shoulders, pinning him gently but absolutely. The Captain moved to his right, her hip brushing against his side. Their scents lingering, a reminder of the transcendent pleasure he had just experienced.

He closed his eyes, focusing on that memory, letting it fill him. The Captain's weight atop him, Riley's mouth on his skin, the shuddering, shared release. He let it all wash over him, a shield against what was to come.

The touch of the cold iron on his skin was a shock, a stark contrast to the warmth of their hands. He flinched, unable to comprehend the true heat burning into his skin. The Captain's hold on the instrument was steady. The sizzle was soft at first, a faint hiss that seemed to suck the air from the room. Then the pain came, not as a sharp slice, but as a deep, building burn, a brand of pure, concentrated fire searing into his flesh. He didn't fight it. He rode the wave of agony, his mind clinging to the memory of their bodies, their touch, the whispered welcome.

And then, as suddenly as it began, it was over. The iron was lifted away. The acute, blazing pain ebbed, leaving behind a throbbing, fiery ache that felt… permanent.

The pressure on his shoulders vanished. He opened his eyes, oxygen returning to his lungs. Riley and the Captain stood on either side of the desk, looking down at him. They were both naked, powerful, and utterly free. Their grins were identical; triumphant, possessive, and blazing with a fierce, shared joy.

The Captain reached out and sliced through the rope at his wrists with a small knife he hadn't seen her draw. Her grey eyes held his, no longer cold, but burning with a new, acknowledged fire.

"You're one of us now, Thomas," she said, her voice ringing with finality. "You're a pirate of the Abyss."

Riley's smile widened, her eyes sparkling with a dark promise.

We hope you enjoyed episode two. For the complete, unfiltered version of this chapter and early access to upcoming releases, join us on Substack. Subscribers stay two weeks ahead and gain access to exclusive art, commentary, and the full version of the scene as it was written.

More Chapters