The hall was finally cleaned, and as afternoon turned to evening, the sun began its slow descent into the ocean. Although it was only their second night, it was the last for Ami and the others. Today was Saturday; they had to return tomorrow and prepare for school on Monday.
Fairy, Erimi, Rin, and Sagiri were less concerned with the schedule. Sagiri was taking online classes—the kind where a camera is placed on her desk at school—so as long as she had internet, she was fine. Her social anxiety was largely managed now; though she was still timid and stuttered around strangers, she could leave the house without issue. By the next semester, she planned to wear her uniform and attend in person.
For their final dinner on the island, the choice was obvious: BBQ!
Rin set up the grill while Fairy defrosted the skewers she'd pre-ordered. Ami and Maki turned on the beach lights and lit a small bonfire, while Megumi buzzed around snapping photos. Sagiri and Erimi were still at their tablets—even though Erimi had conceded defeat earlier, the two were still locked in a creative rivalry.
Soon, the scent of sizzling fat over charcoal drew the girls to Rin's side. Their bellies were empty, having only "consumed" some of Rin's protein for lunch.
"Megumi, the skewers are almost ready. Go call them."
"On it!~~"
Lured by the aroma, the two artists joined the circle. Rin and Fairy were applying the final spices.
"I didn't know Master was a grill master too... but Emily's will definitely taste better! Give me one!"
Erimi snatched a skewer before it even hit the plate. Ami and the others followed suit, knowing that food always tastes better when you have to fight for it.
"What are we doing later? It's too late for swimming," Megumi asked between bites. The morning's NTR play had been thrilling, but they wanted to make the most of their getaway.
"Want to continue the RPG from the other night?" Maki suggested.
"By the way," Erimi asked, "how far did you guys get?" She was now certain that night hadn't been a dream. If she hadn't tried to "save" Fairy back then, the next day's party might never have happened.
"That night..." Ami blushed. "Our 'Dawn Adventurer Party' had already been Ravaged by slimes, orcs, and werewolves."
"...You guys lost on purpose, didn't you!?"
"No, we really didn't," Fairy replied, her lip twitching. She had only thrown the initial gear-buying phase to help Erimi "give up." Once Erimi had passed out, it was a real game—except that "losing" had specific consequences. For example, losing to the Orcs meant being dragged to a cave to be used as breeding stock. Naturally, Rin played the role of the Orc.
"Our luck was just terrible. Every check failed," Megumi sighed. "Whether it was combat or a random event, the result was always Sexual Slavery."
Rin stifled a laugh. They had stepped into slime traps and been robbed by thieves. When they tried to fight the thieves to get their gear back, they lost and were taken as slaves.
"I think it's the name. Change the party name and your luck will change," Rin suggested.
"What's wrong with 'Dawn Adventurers'?" Sagiri challenged. "It was just a bad night. Let's play again after dinner!"
"We can play RPGs at home," Ami whispered, her toes curling in the sand. Maki knew that look—Ami wanted sex but was too shy to say it. Looks like another sleepless night.
Maki wondered what Ami had in mind. Roleplaying as adventurers being ravaged by monsters was fun, but Ami clearly wanted something else. "Ami, what do you want to play?"
"This island is so big and we haven't explored it... How about... an expedition tonight?" Ami's voice trailed off.
"An expedition, huh?" Maki sighed. Everyone except Erimi knew what she meant. Why "explore" at night? It wasn't about the scenery; it was about the thrill of public exposure.
Fairy's father's island used to be a bustling resort. There were asphalt roads, abandoned shops, and restaurants along the beach. Though the businesses were closed, the area felt like a ghost town—far more exciting than Karen's tiny private island. The risk of being "seen," even if the island was empty, provided an exquisite tension.
"I... I can show you around," Fairy said shyly. She remembered the island when it was full of people.
"Wait a second... I need to grab something!" Ami ran back into the hotel. "And some water! It's a long walk... I almost forgot."
Watching Erimi's innocent face, Maki sighed while Fairy giggled. Water? You'll be lucky if you don't end up dehydrated from squirting!
Ami returned carrying a small box, her face already flushed.
"What's that?" Erimi asked. "I didn't see that in the luggage."
Fairy smiled. Erimi hadn't seen it because Karen had sent it over secretly via the maid, Sakurako. Ami opened the box to reveal several furry items.
Erimi's eyes widened. She recognized these from her "research" for drawing smut. "Cat ears? No... fox ears? Why? And these tails... WAIT! What kind of tail is THAT!?"
Attached to the fluffy fox tails were smooth, stainless steel anal plugs.
"I... I have to wear that? No way! My ass hasn't been 'developed' yet! I'll just wear the headband!"
"You can't draw a soulful manga without personal experience," Rin said with a straight face. "Mashiro did the same thing back in the day... right, Fairy?"
Fairy caught his wink immediately. "That's right! Mashiro did 'body research' for all her work. Besides, Erimi, you'd look so cute in this."
Erimi couldn't resist Fairy's praise. But one thing bothered her. "Mashiro... you mean the world-famous genius painter, Mashiro Shiina?"
Erimi was a talented artist herself, but Mashiro was her idol. She'd assumed it was just a common name, but the context was getting suspicious.
"The one and only," Fairy smirked. "Rin even has photos of Mashiro in a cat-girl outfit. Want to see?"
Erimi swallowed hard. "Master... can I?"
"No," Rin shook his head. He did have photos—not just cat-girl ones, but shots of her "baby's room" being held open by a speculum. But he couldn't show those without Mashiro's consent. Seeing Erimi's disappointment, he added: "But if you wear it, I'll take you to meet her."
"I'll wear it! Right now!" Erimi grabbed the fox ears. But the tail... "I'll... I'll go to the bathroom to put it in."
"No need! We're all friends here. We'll help you," Megumi teased, closing in.
"Wait! No! STAY AWAY! AAAAHHHH!"
Before she could blink, the girls had surrounded her. Her T-shirt, shorts, and underwear were gone in ten seconds.
"I can do it my—MMPH!"
Fairy stuffed the metal end of a tail into Erimi's mouth to silence her while she felt the soft fur. "The texture is great."
Fairy lubricated the plug, knelt behind Erimi, and lined it up with her puckered anus. A mischievous, "chunibyo" grin crossed her face.
"Secret Art of the Flame Fairy! FAIRY IMPACT!!!!"
"GUUUUUEEEEEE!!!!"
Erimi's eyes rolled back. If Ami hadn't been holding her, she would have collapsed. Her ass was virgin territory, and the "System buff" from Rin's fluids had long since worn off.
"Hah... hah... Emily... you're too rough..."
Erimi stood shakily, feeling like Fairy had literally shoved the pee out of her. Rin's thing is way bigger than this... how was Emily enjoying it so much this morning? She couldn't understand it. And she really didn't want to be "penetrated" again.