CHAPTER 17: GAME NIGHT INTERRUPTED
Friday night, and the attic had transformed into something between war room and community center.
Kol sat behind his DM screen, surrounded by maps and miniatures and dice that clattered with the weight of actual political consequences. The campaign had reached its climax—the party faced an ancient red dragon guarding a hoard that contained the artifact needed to save the kingdom.
But the real drama was happening between players.
Diego's fighter and a young witch named Claire argued about resource distribution, their in-character dispute barely masking real territorial tensions that had been simmering for weeks.
"My character found the healing potions," Diego insisted. "They're mine."
"Your character would have died three encounters ago without my healing spells," Claire countered. "The potions should be distributed based on need, not who picked them up first."
"That's not how loot works—"
"Gentlemen, lady," Kol interrupted smoothly, channeling his best corporate mediator voice. "Perhaps we could resolve this through the campaign? The dragon's hoard contains enough treasure for everyone. But you'll need to work together to defeat it first."
Marcel watched from his position by the window, arms crossed, clearly wondering if his investment in dice and character sheets was about to combust into actual violence.
Davina, playing her bard, attempted diplomacy. "My character suggests we focus on the immediate threat and discuss distribution after we survive."
"Sensible," Elijah said mildly. His paladin had become the party's moral center, which amused everyone who knew the Original vampire's complicated history.
The dragon's turn came up in initiative. Kol was about to describe its devastating breath weapon when—
The door exploded inward.
Five werewolves stormed into the attic, led by a muscular man radiating barely-controlled aggression. They burst through with the energy of people expecting combat, weapons drawn, ready for violence.
Then they stopped, confusion evident on every face.
The attic was packed with vampires, witches, and humans sitting around a table covered in dice, character sheets, and miniature figures. Pizza boxes were stacked in the corner. Someone had brought cookies. The only weapons visible were plastic swords used as pointing implements.
Silence stretched, broken only by the clicking of dice as Josh nervously rolled his d20.
"What... is this?" the lead werewolf—Oliver, Kol's memory supplied—asked slowly.
"We're slaying dragons," Josh said, deadpan despite visible nervousness. "You interrupted the boss fight."
A werewolf in the back squinted at the table. "Is that pizza?"
"Supreme and pepperoni," Diego confirmed. "You want some?"
Oliver's expression cycled through confusion, suspicion, and reluctant curiosity. "We came to discuss territorial boundaries. Heard vampires were gathering in force."
"We are gathering," Marcel said. "For game night. Every Friday. It's a diplomatic initiative."
"You're playing pretend," Oliver said flatly.
"We're engaging in collaborative storytelling as team-building exercise," Kol corrected, then caught himself. "Yes. Playing pretend. Would you like to join?"
The werewolves exchanged glances, clearly uncertain how to process this development.
Kol saw an opportunity and seized it. "You want to talk territory? Fine. House rules: no violence during game night. But if you're here, you play. We were just about to fight a dragon that requires full party cooperation. Six people instead of four would significantly improve our odds."
"You want us to join your game," Oliver said slowly.
"Unless you'd prefer to start a territorial war over a D&D session interruption," Kol replied. "Which would be embarrassing for everyone involved."
Oliver studied the table, the dice, the character sheets filled with stats and abilities. Something shifted in his expression—recognition, maybe. "I played this. Back in high school. Before..." He gestured vaguely at himself, encompassing the werewolf curse and everything it represented.
"Then you know how it works," Kol said. "Sit. Make characters. Help us kill a dragon."
The other werewolves looked to Oliver, who shrugged and pulled up a chair. "Fine. But if this is some kind of trap—"
"It's a red dragon with breath weapon and legendary actions," Kol interrupted. "The only trap is inadequate preparation."
Character creation for five werewolves took twenty minutes and resulted in exactly what Kol expected—five barbarians with slightly different weapon preferences.
"We're combat optimized," Oliver said defensively when Davina raised an eyebrow.
"No judgment," she replied. "Just noting that our party composition now includes six melee fighters, one healer, and one bard. This will be interesting."
Kol adjusted the campaign on the fly, scaling the dragon's stats and adding environmental hazards that required tactical thinking over pure damage output. The party needed to cooperate—vampires and witches and werewolves working together—or they'd all die horribly.
And somehow, impossibly, it worked.
Diego and Oliver's characters coordinated flanking maneuvers. Claire healed both vampire and werewolf fighters without discrimination. The werewolf barbarians provided raw damage while Davina's bard offered crucial support buffs. Elijah's paladin anchored the frontline with aristocratic efficiency.
Real grudges were addressed through roleplay. When a werewolf character accused a vampire character of hoarding resources, the in-game dispute became a proxy for real territorial conflicts, resolved through dice rolls and collaborative problem-solving rather than violence.
Three hours later, the dragon fell.
The table erupted in cheers—vampires and werewolves and witches celebrating together, high-fiving across factional lines that had seemed insurmountable hours earlier.
"That was..." Oliver searched for words. "Not terrible."
"High praise," Marcel muttered, but he was smiling.
"Same time next week?" Kol asked.
The agreement was immediate and universal. Even Oliver nodded, grudging but genuine.
During the break while people filed out, a shy werewolf girl approached Kol. She'd been lingering at the edge of the game, not playing but watching with hungry interest.
"You're Kol Mikaelson?" she asked quietly.
"Guilty." Kol studied her, and his void sense tingled—that familiar warning that suggested significance he couldn't quite articulate. "And you are?"
"Hayley Marshall." She twisted her hands together, nervous energy radiating from her. "I heard... people say you're the Original who helps people. That you're different from the stories."
"Depends on what you need help with," Kol said carefully.
Hayley glanced around, ensuring privacy, then met his eyes with desperate determination. "I'm pregnant. On the run from my pack. I need somewhere safe to hide."
Kol's breath caught. The void visions flooded back—Hayley pregnant, defiant, standing in a compound with Klaus looming over her. Hope crying. The baby that would change everything.
"It's starting. The convergence. Klaus's arrival. Everything I've been preparing for."
"Who's the father?" he asked, though he already suspected.
"I can't—" Hayley's voice cracked. "I can't tell you that. But he doesn't know. And if he finds out, I don't know if he'll kill me or keep me prisoner. Either way, I can't let him control my baby."
Klaus. It had to be Klaus. The timeline aligned perfectly with his void visions.
"I'll help," Kol said immediately. "Stay in the Quarter. I'll arrange housing, protection, everything you need."
"Why?" Hayley searched his face for deception. "You don't know me. Why help?"
Because the baby you're carrying is my niece, Kol thought. Because she's the most important person in the coming war. Because I've seen what happens if I don't protect you both.
"Because everyone deserves safety," he said aloud. "Especially pregnant women on the run. Let me help."
Hayley's eyes filled with tears. "Thank you. I didn't know where else to go."
Kol walked her out, making mental notes about security arrangements and how to explain this to Marcel without revealing his knowledge of the baby's paternity. The void whispers hummed with satisfaction, pleased that pieces were moving into position.
Above them, stars wheeled through their patterns, indifferent to supernatural drama.
But in North Carolina, Klaus Mikaelson received his brother's latest letter.
KLAUS POV
The envelope lay on Klaus's desk, Elijah's precise handwriting unmistakable. He'd been avoiding it for an hour, knowing that whatever news his noble brother deemed important enough to write about would complicate his existence.
Finally, he opened it.
"Brother, developments in New Orleans require your attention. Kol has established himself as significant power player—treaties between factions, magical innovations, political alliances. He's changed in ways I cannot fully articulate. You should see for yourself. Additionally, there are matters we must discuss regarding the city's future. - E."
Klaus read it three times, each pass making his fury build higher.
Kol. Kol, his wayward, chaotic, impossible little brother had been alive for three months and hadn't bothered to inform him. Had instead built a power base in Klaus's city, made alliances with Klaus's former protégé, apparently become a completely different person.
The glass in Klaus's hand shattered, bourbon and blood mixing on the desk.
"KOL!" he roared, though his brother was a thousand miles away.
Caroline appeared in the doorway, drawn by the noise. "Everything okay?"
"No." Klaus stood, pacing like a caged wolf. "My brother—one of them—has been resurrected. Been alive for months. And no one thought to inform me."
"Which brother?"
"Kol. The one I've daggered more times than I can count because he couldn't go five minutes without causing chaos." Klaus crumpled the letter. "Apparently he's become a diplomat now. Treaties and alliances. Elijah practically glowing with pride in this letter."
"Maybe he has changed," Caroline suggested carefully.
"Mikaelsons don't change," Klaus said bitterly. "We just find new ways to betray each other."
But underneath the fury, curiosity burned. What had happened during Kol's resurrection to alter him so fundamentally? What was his brother planning? And why did the thought of Kol building something in New Orleans fill Klaus with equal parts rage and jealousy?
"I'm going to New Orleans," Klaus declared. "Time to see what my brother has become."
Caroline sighed. "When?"
"Soon." Klaus stared at the ruined letter. "Very soon."
Back in New Orleans, unaware of the storm he'd just unleashed, Kol helped Hayley settle into a safe house two blocks from the compound.
The void whispers hummed their approval.
Convergence was approaching.
And Kol had just ensured he'd be at the center of it.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0