Cherreads

Chapter 17 - If Circumstances Were Different

The message arrived at 14:47, three words that disrupted the careful equilibrium I'd been maintaining for the past five days.

Meet me in The Quiet Suite. 15:00. Not a session. —M.S.L.

I stared at my tablet, sitting cross-legged on the window seat in Suite 3. It was Day 11—five days since Session Two, still sixty hours until Session Three.

The Integration Period was meant to be exactly that: integration. Time to process the psychological breakthroughs without new stimuli, to allow the nervous system to recalibrate, to metabolize the experience of surrender without the Praxist's presence complicating the analysis.

Meric had never contacted me during an Integration Period before.

Not a session.

The clarification should have been reassuring. Instead, it made my pulse quicken in a way I recognized too well—the same physiological response I'd experienced when his thumb had pressed against the inside of my wrist on Day 1, when he'd touched my face after Session Two, when I'd realized that the tremor in his hand hadn't been accidental.

I read the message three more times, as if repetition would reveal some hidden clinical purpose I'd missed. But the words remained stubbornly ambiguous. An invitation without context. A summons without justification.

Not a session?

Which meant: not Praxist and client. Not the structured power dynamic we'd negotiated and signed into Protocol. Something else entirely.

I had thirteen minutes to decide if I was going to show up.

The Quiet Suite was located in the Observation Wing, halfway between Meric's private office and the administrative spaces Vigdis controlled with tactical precision. I'd glimpsed it briefly during my accidental wrong turn on Day 4—the one that had ended with me discovering the locked steel box on Meric's desk and Vigdis's warning about boundaries.

But I'd never been invited inside.

The door was open when I arrived at precisely 15:00. Not early. Not late. I'd spent three minutes in the bathroom checking my reflection—an impulse I immediately recognized as the same maladaptive behavior pattern I counseled patients against. Seeking external validation. Attempting to control perception through appearance.

I was wearing black leggings and an oversized gray sweater, the same style I'd worn every day since arrival. My hair was pulled into its usual ponytail. No makeup. Nothing deliberate.

Except I'd changed the sweater twice before leaving Suite 3.

The Quiet Suite was smaller than I'd imagined—perhaps twenty feet square, with floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the fjord's eastern expanse. The space felt fundamentally different from every other room in the Institute. Warmer. The walls were a soft charcoal rather than the clinical gray of the sessions chamber, and a low fire burned in a stone fireplace set into the north wall. Two leather armchairs faced the fire, separated by a small table holding a carafe of water and two glasses. Bookshelves lined the remaining walls, filled with what appeared to be Meric's personal collection rather than the Institute's curated library.

He was standing by the window, his back to the door, hands clasped behind him.

He wasn't dressed in black.

The observation landed with unexpected weight. I'd only ever seen Meric in his Praxist uniform—fitted black trousers, black shirt with sleeves rolled to the forearms, the kind of deliberate simplicity that communicated control without ornamentation. But today he wore dark gray wool trousers and a navy sweater, the collar of a white shirt visible at his neck.

He looked softer. More human. Less like a clinician and more like someone who might exist outside these walls, who might have a life that didn't revolve entirely around administering Praxis.

"Come in," he said without turning around. His voice carried the same controlled tone I recognized from sessions, but something in the timbre had shifted. Less formal. Almost uncertain.

I stepped inside, leaving the door open behind me—a small act of boundary preservation that felt both necessary and insufficient.

"You can close it," Meric said, finally turning to face me. "This isn't a violation of Protocol. Clause 6.8 permits non-session interaction in communal spaces during Integration Periods, provided both parties consent, and no therapeutic work occurs."

Of course, he would lead with the Protocol justification. Clinical framing to contain whatever this was.

I closed the door.

"Why am I here?" I asked.

He hesitated—a micro-pause that lasted perhaps half a second, but on Meric, hesitation was as conspicuous as shouting. "I thought you might appreciate a conversation that doesn't involve Surrender Articulation or Cadence adjustments."

"A conversation about what?" I asked.

"Anything except Praxis." He said calmly.

The answer was so unexpected that I almost laughed. "You're aware that Praxis is the only reason I know you exist."

"I'm aware." He moved away from the window, gesturing toward the armchairs. "But you've spent eleven days analyzing every word I say through a therapeutic lens. I thought it might be... useful to interact outside that dynamic. Temporarily."

"Useful for whom?"

There it was again—the same question I'd asked him on Day 2 about evening sessions. For me or for you?

His jaw tightened slightly. "For both of us, perhaps."

I should have declined. The professional boundary was clear: Praxists and clients maintained separation outside formal sessions to prevent transference contamination. The relationship existed to serve the work, not to satisfy personal curiosity.

But I sat down in the chair closest to the fire anyway.

For the first five minutes, neither of us spoke.

Meric had taken the opposite chair, and we sat in the kind of weighted silence that felt both uncomfortable and strangely companionable. The fire crackled softly, and through the windows, I could see the afternoon light beginning its early winter fade toward darkness.

"I've been thinking about your Core Lie," Meric said finally.

I looked at him sharply. "That sounds like therapeutic work."

"It's philosophical observation." He leaned forward slightly, resting his forearms on his knees. "You believe control equals power. That if you can manage every variable—your patients' outcomes, your mother's medication schedule, your own emotional responses—you'll be safe from loss."

"We've established that already."

"We have." He paused, his pale gray eyes reflecting the firelight. "But I've been wondering if my Core Lie is the inverse of yours."

That pulled my attention fully. In four sessions and eleven days, Meric had never offered anything personal. Every revelation had been calculated, every disclosure measured against its therapeutic utility.

"Which is?" I asked.

"That if I maintain perfect clinical objectivity, I can guide people through transformation without being transformed myself." His voice remained even, but something in his expression had shifted—a subtle crack in the facade. "That the Praxist stands outside the work, unchanged by the people who surrender to him."

"And you're realizing that's not true," I observed.

"I'm realizing," he said carefully, "that fifteen years of adherence to Clause 7.3 doesn't make me immune to..." He stopped, seeming to reconsider his phrasing. "To recognizing when someone sees through the methodology to the person administering it."

My heart rate accelerated. This was dangerous territory—not just boundary-adjacent but actively violating the implicit contract that kept our interactions safe.

"You're saying I see you," I said slowly, testing the words.

"I'm saying you see through me. Which is different." He sat back, creating physical distance even as the emotional proximity intensified. "Most clients see the Praxist. The role. The authority figure who holds their surrender. You see the construction. The performance. The places where the clinical detachment is effortful rather than natural."

He wasn't wrong. From the first conversation in his office, I'd noticed the micro-adjustments—the way he'd return to "Dr. Kaelen" when I got too familiar, the controlled modulation of his voice when questions landed too close to something personal, the careful phrasing that revealed more in what he didn't say than what he did.

I'd been reading him the same way I read my patients. Attending to the subtext. Analyzing the defense mechanisms.

"Is that why you invited me here?" I asked. "Because I see the performance?"

"I invited you here because..." He stopped again, and for the first time since I'd met him, Meric looked genuinely uncertain. "Because I wanted to have one conversation where I'm not performing. Where I don't have to maintain the clinical distance that protects the work."

"The distance protects both of us," I said quietly. "Not just the work."

"I know."

We sat with that admission between us, the fire the only sound in the room. Outside, the sky had darkened to charcoal, and the fjord below reflected nothing—just black water against blacker stone.

"Tell me about your training," I said, pivoting to safer ground. "How does someone become a Praxist?"

Meric's expression shifted—not quite relief, but something close to it. Permission to retreat into professional history rather than personal revelation.

"Three years of certification," he said. "Psychology, neuroscience, hands-on supervised practice. The Institute accepts fewer than five percent of applicants. Most wash out in the first year because they can't maintain the psychological boundaries required."

"And you could."

"I learned to." He paused, his gaze distant. "I was twenty-six when my father died. Grief-raw. Angry at everyone who'd tried to corrupt what he built. The certification program gave me something to focus on besides loss."

"Your father founded the Institute."

"Fifteen years ago. He wanted to prove that power exchange could be transformative rather than exploitative. That BDSM could be reframed as applied behavioral psychology—Praxis—without losing the psychological intensity that makes it effective."

I leaned forward, the clinical part of my brain engaging despite my attempt to remain outside the therapeutic dynamic. "And you took over when he died."

"I inherited the legal entity. I had to earn the right to lead it." His voice carried an edge I hadn't heard before—not anger, but something sharper. "There were people who wanted to weaponize the methodology. Turn it into a tool for compliance engineering rather than self-actualization."

"The partner you mentioned before," I observed.

His eyes met mine, and I saw recognition there—the awareness that I'd been paying attention, cataloging details, building my own dossier on him.

"Yes," he said simply.

"And you cut them out."

"I chose the therapeutic path. She chose power." He stood abruptly, moving to the bookshelf as if the proximity had become too much. "I've spent twelve years protecting that choice. Making sure every client who walks through these doors experiences Praxis as liberation, not manipulation."

I watched him run his fingers along the spine of a book—something about Scandinavian philosophy, the title in Norwegian. His hand trembled slightly, the same micro-movement I'd noticed after Session Two.

"What did she want to do with the methodology?" I asked.

"Create predictable compliance in high-value targets. Politicians. CEOs. Intelligence assets." His voice had gone flat. "She believed that if you could engineer someone's surrender response, you could program them. Remove their agency while making them believe they were choosing submission."

The horror of it landed slowly, spreading through my chest like cold water. Everything I'd experienced in our sessions—the psychological excavation, the careful negotiation of consent, the emphasis on my choice to surrender—inverted into something monstrous.

"That's not Praxis," I said.

"No." He turned back to face me, and his expression held something that looked almost like gratitude. "That's why I refused her. That's why I built Clause 7.3 into the Protocol. Because the moment the Praxist needs the client's surrender for personal gratification or control, it stops being therapeutic and becomes abuse."

He'd moved back toward the chairs while speaking, and now we were standing perhaps three feet apart, close enough that I could see the firelight reflected in his eyes, the slight tension in his jaw, the way his hands remained carefully at his sides as if he didn't trust himself to gesture.

"Is that why you're so careful with me?" I asked, my voice quieter than I intended. "Because you're afraid of repeating her mistakes?"

"I'm careful with you," Meric said, his voice low and controlled, "because you make me want to break every rule I've spent fifteen years maintaining."

The admission hung between us, impossible to ignore or retract.

My breath caught. This was the line we'd been circling since Day 1—the boundary neither of us had been willing to name directly. And now Meric had not just acknowledged it but pulled it into sharp, explicit focus.

"That's a Clause 7.3 violation," I managed.

"It's the truth." He didn't move closer, but I felt the distance between us contract anyway, as if honesty created its own form of proximity. "And I'm telling you because you deserve to know that every decision I make about your Cadence, every session I design, is shaped by the fact that I'm compromised."

"How compromised?"

He held my gaze for a long moment, and I watched the internal debate play across his face—the Praxist wrestling with the man, clinical objectivity fighting against whatever he actually felt.

"Enough that Vigdis warned me," he said finally. "Enough that I've watched Session Two four times. Enough that I'm standing here having this conversation instead of maintaining the professional distance that would protect both of us."

I should have been angry. This was a massive ethical violation—a therapist admitting attraction to a client mid-treatment, compromising the integrity of the work we'd contracted to complete. I should have demanded reassignment, filed a complaint, walked out of the Institute entirely.

Instead, I felt something else entirely. Relief. Validation. The confirmation that what I'd been experiencing wasn't one-sided transference but genuine, mutual recognition.

"I see you too," I said quietly.

Meric's expression shifted—surprise, then something darker and more complex. "Aethelreda—"

"Not Dr. Kaelen. Not the client. Not the person paying two hundred thousand dollars for twelve weeks of behavioral therapy." I took a half-step closer, closing the distance he'd been carefully maintaining. "I see Meric. The man who trembles when he touches me. Who designs sessions to protect himself as much as advance my Cadence. Who stands in this room wearing a navy sweater instead of Praxist black because he wants one conversation where he's not performing."

"This is dangerous." He said, but he didn't move away.

"I know," I replied with a voice that was just above a whisper.

We were close enough now that I could see the rapid pulse at the base of his throat, the slight dilation of his pupils, the way his hands had curled into loose fists as if physical restraint was the only thing preventing him from reaching for me.

The air between us felt charged, heavy with everything we weren't saying. I could smell the faint scent of his cologne—something clean and understated, cedar and salt. Could hear the slight catch in his breathing that matched my own.

Meric lifted one hand slowly, as if moving through water, and I thought he was going to touch my face the way he had after Session Two. But his hand stopped midway, hovering in the space between us, and I realized he was reaching past me toward the bookshelf behind my shoulder.

His forearm brushed against mine—the barest contact, cotton sleeve against bare skin—and the touch sent an electric current through my entire nervous system.

We both froze.

His eyes met mine, and for a moment I saw everything he'd been carefully concealing: desire, yes, but also fear and longing and something that looked devastatingly like tenderness.

Then he closed the distance.

Not all of it. Just enough that I could feel the heat radiating from his body, could see the individual shades of gray in his eyes, could count the breaths between one heartbeat and the next.

"Aethelreda," he whispered, my name both question and warning.

I tilted my face up slightly, a movement so small it could have been unconscious, but we both knew it wasn't.

He leaned forward.

I held my breath.

And then—

He pulled back abruptly, stepping away and putting the armchair between us like a physical barrier.

"I'm sorry." His voice had gone rough, strained. "That was—I shouldn't have—"

"Meric—"

"You should go." He wouldn't look at me, his attention fixed somewhere past my shoulder. "Session Three is still scheduled for Day 10. The theme is Reflection. The Integration Period continues."

The clinical language hit like cold water, snapping us both back into our designated roles. Praxist and client. Professional boundaries. The Protocol we'd signed.

But my hands were shaking, and I could see the tension in his shoulders, the rigid control he was exerting to keep himself from turning back around.

"Why did you invite me here?" I asked again, my voice barely steady.

"Because I'm an idiot," he said quietly. "Because I wanted to know what it felt like to talk to you as equals. To see you outside the power dynamic. To pretend, for one hour, that you weren't my client and I wasn't your Praxist."

"And?"

"And now I know." He finally turned to face me, and his expression was so carefully blank it was almost painful to witness. "And it's worse than I thought."

"Worse how?"

"Because now I know what I'm giving up," Meric said, his voice raw with something that sounded like grief. "Now I know that if circumstances were different—if you'd walked into my life outside these walls, if we'd met in Boston or Oslo or anywhere that didn't involve a two-hundred-thousand-dollar contract and Clause 7.3—I would have kissed you. And I would have asked you to stay."

The admission cracked something open in my chest, painful and exhilarating simultaneously.

"But circumstances aren't different," I said.

"No." He moved toward the door, opening it in clear dismissal. "You're my client. I'm your Praxist. And we have seven more weeks of contracted work to complete. So I'm asking you to leave, Aethelreda. Before I do something we'll both regret."

I walked toward the door, my legs unsteady beneath me, hyper-aware of his proximity as I passed him in the doorframe. Our shoulders nearly touched, separated by perhaps two inches of charged space.

I paused at the threshold.

"For the record," I said without looking back, "I would have let you kiss me. And I would have stayed."

I didn't wait for his response.

The walk back to the East Wing felt interminable. My pulse was still elevated, my hands still trembling, and every nerve ending in my body felt raw and exposed as if I'd been flayed open and left to process the experience without any protective barrier.

Vigdis was in the corridor near the boundary doors, her pale blue eyes tracking my movement with unsettling precision.

"Dr. Kaelen," she said evenly.

"Vigdis," I said, but I didn't slow down.

"You were in The Quiet Suite."

It wasn't a question. Of course, she knew. Vigdis knew everything that happened in these walls.

"Meric invited me," I said, my voice sharper than intended. "It wasn't a session. Clause 6.8 permits non-session interaction during—"

"I'm aware of what Clause 6.8 permits." She stepped into my path, forcing me to stop. "I'm also aware that Clause 7.3 prohibits exactly what I just watched happen through the security feed."

My stomach dropped. "You were watching."

"I monitor all Institute spaces. It's my job." Her expression remained neutral, professional. "And what I saw was two people violating the emotional boundary that protects the integrity of the work. He didn't kiss you. But he wanted to. And you wanted him to. That's enough."

She was right, and we both knew it. The physical act was irrelevant. The boundary violation had occurred the moment Meric admitted I made him want to break rules, the moment I'd told him I saw through his performance, the moment we'd both acknowledged that if circumstances were different, we would choose each other.

"Are you going to terminate the contract?" I asked.

Vigdis studied me for a long moment, her gaze analytical and assessing. "No," she said finally. "Because Meric pulled away. Because you both recognized the line and chose not to cross it. And because you have seven weeks of legitimate therapeutic work remaining that you paid for and deserve to complete."

Relief flooded through me, followed immediately by something more complicated. Disappointment, maybe. Or frustration that the boundaries we'd acknowledged were the same boundaries we'd have to maintain.

"But," Vigdis continued, her voice hardening, "if either of you crosses that line again before your twelve weeks conclude, I will terminate the contract immediately. And I will document the violation in your Client Dossier, which means you'll never be permitted to return to this Institute. Do you understand?"

"I understand."

"Do you?" She leaned closer, her voice dropping. "Because from where I'm standing, you're both making this harder than it needs to be. You came here to break through your control patterns, not to fall in love with your Praxist. And he's supposed to be guiding you through transformation, not compromising his entire professional foundation because you're the first client who's ever seen him as human."

The words landed with brutal accuracy.

"I didn't mean to—"

"It doesn't matter what you meant." Vigdis stepped back, her professional mask sliding back into place. "What matters is what you do next. Session Three is in three days. Complete the work you came here to do. Process your surrender. Transform. And then walk away. Because staying—trying to turn this into something it can't be while you're still his client—will destroy both of you."

She walked away before I could respond, her footsteps silent on the polished floor.

I stood alone in the corridor, the boundary doors closed behind me, the East Wing stretching out before me like a different country entirely.

Vigdis was right about everything.

I'd come to the Institute to shatter my Core Lie, to discover that control wasn't power and that surrender could be an act of self-possession rather than weakness. I'd paid two hundred thousand dollars and signed away twelve weeks of my life to experience the psychological excavation that only Praxis could provide.

I hadn't come here to fall in love with Meric Solvang-Lykke.

But as I walked back to Suite 3, past the library and the meditation room and the communal spaces designed for integration and processing, I felt the truth settle into my bones with undeniable clarity:

I was falling for him anyway.

Not for the Praxist. Not for the methodology or the power dynamic or the clinical precision with which he administered the work.

I was falling for the man in the navy sweater who'd admitted he was compromised, who'd pulled away because he valued my transformation more than his own desire, who'd looked at me with raw honesty and said If circumstances were different.

And that—that specific, dangerous, boundary-violating want—was the most reckless thing I'd ever allowed myself to feel.

Because Vigdis was right.

We still had seven weeks.

And every day of those seven weeks, I would have to walk into sessions with Meric, surrender to his commands, allow him to excavate my psychological defenses, and pretend that the person guiding me through The Edge wasn't the same person I wanted to pull me over it and catch me when I fell.

This was going to destroy us both.

But I didn't know how to stop it.

More Chapters