Chapter 57: The Investment Club
"We want you to manage our money."
Leonard delivers this like he's been rehearsing.
We're at my penthouse. Pizza night, but Howard and Bernadette left early. Penny's at work. It's just the four of them sitting across from me with the unified determination of a corporate board.
"No."
"We haven't even explained—"
"Still no."
Sheldon pulls out a folder. Actual physical folder with printed documents.
"We've prepared a formal proposal."
"Of course you have."
He opens it. Charts. Graphs. A comprehensive analysis of my investment history.
"Your Bitcoin investment: 900% return in eighteen months. Your Apple position: 340% return. Your March 2008 purchase of Amazon: 180% return. Your predictive accuracy is statistically anomalous."
"Lucky guesses."
"Twenty-three consecutive lucky guesses?" Sheldon's eyebrow rises. "The probability of that is 0.000000047%."
"So you're saying there's a chance."
"We want in," Howard says simply. "Five thousand each. Twenty thousand total. You invest it however you think best."
"Guys—"
"Stuart." Leonard leans forward. "You've made over a hundred thousand dollars from investments in less than two years. We've been watching. We know you're doing something right. We trust you."
That's the problem.
They trust me.
They trust that I earned this knowledge through research and brilliance and hard work.
Not through stealing memories from a future that shouldn't exist.
"I can't."
"Why not?" Raj asks. "You've been helping everyone else. The shops are doing great. Your consulting is amazing. Why won't you help us with this?"
Because managing your own cheating is one thing. Managing someone else's stake in that cheating is completely different.
"What if I lose your money?"
"You won't," Leonard says with disturbing confidence.
"But what if I do? What if my luck runs out? What if—"
"Then we lose five thousand dollars." Sheldon closes his folder. "We've calculated the risk. We're comfortable with it. The expected value of trusting your judgment significantly outweighs the potential loss."
"Sheldon—"
"Stuart, we're asking you to do this because we believe in you. Let us invest in that belief. Literally."
Twenty minutes later, I've agreed to the worst idea I've had since reincarnating.
But with conditions.
"No speculative stuff," I insist. "No Bitcoin. No penny stocks. No gambling on startups."
"Why not?" Howard protests. "Your Bitcoin—"
"Is too volatile. I got lucky with timing. I won't risk your money on cryptocurrency."
Lie. I got lucky with foreknowledge. But I can't risk their money on something I can't explain if it crashes before the big surge.
"Then what?" Leonard has his checkbook out.
"Index funds. Blue chip stocks. Apple, Google, Amazon. Safe, predictable growth."
"Boring," Raj mutters.
"Boring keeps your money growing instead of evaporating."
Sheldon's already drafting agreements on his laptop.
"I'll create a standard investment management contract. Including clauses absolving you of liability in case of market downturns, requiring quarterly reports on portfolio performance, and establishing a fiduciary relationship wherein—"
"English, Sheldon."
"Legal protection so we can't sue you if things go badly."
"I'm not signing anything that says you can't sue me. If I lose your money through negligence or stupidity, you should be able to sue."
This gives them pause.
"You're really that confident?" Leonard asks.
"I'm really that committed to doing this right."
After they leave—checks written, agreements signed, Sheldon's legal framework approved by everyone—I sit alone with twenty thousand dollars of other people's money.
My laptop's open. Brokerage account ready.
I could put this in Bitcoin. Turn their $20k into $200k in three years. Make them genuinely wealthy.
But I can't explain that certainty. Can't justify the risk on paper.
So instead: Apple (splitting soon, will double), Google (steady growth), Amazon (cloud computing boom coming), Microsoft (renaissance under Ballmer's eventual replacement).
Safe. Boring. Predictable.
Will probably double their money in three years. Maybe triple.
Not the massive windfall they could have. But sustainable, explainable growth.
I set up five separate accounts. $4,000 each after my 20% management fee (insisted on by Sheldon for "proper fiduciary structure").
Leonard: 40% Apple, 30% Google, 30% Amazon.
Sheldon: 35% each Apple/Google/Amazon, 5% bonds (he insisted on "risk diversification").
Howard: 50% Apple, 25% Google, 25% aerospace ETF (thematic, he appreciated it).
Raj: 40% tech sector, 60% international index (emerging markets will boom).
Hit execute on all trades.
Twenty thousand dollars of their money now in the market.
Based on my stolen knowledge.
For their benefit.
My phone rings. Penny.
"Hey! Break between tables. How'd the investment thing go?"
"They gave me twenty thousand dollars to invest."
"That's—wait, that's a lot of responsibility."
"Yeah."
"You okay?"
"I'm managing my friends' life savings based on hunches and luck. What could go wrong?"
"Stuart. You've made incredible decisions so far. They trust you for a reason."
"But what if—"
"What if nothing. You're smart. You're careful. You care about them. That's all anyone can ask."
I want to tell her the truth. That every investment is based on foreknowledge. That I'm cheating. That their trust is misplaced because I didn't earn this ability.
Instead: "Thanks. I needed to hear that."
"Anytime. Now stop spiraling and go do whatever rich people do with spreadsheets."
"I'm not rich."
"You have a penthouse and Marvel money and apparently everyone wants you to invest their savings. You're rich."
Fair.
After we hang up, I create a separate document.
INVESTMENT_ETHICS.doc
If their portfolios lose money for any reason, I will:
Cover losses from personal fundsReturn their original investment plus 5% interestNever ask them to invest with me again
If their portfolios make money, I will:
Take only actual management fees, no performance bonusReport honestly on market conditionsRecommend they take profits at reasonable intervalsNever pressure them to stay invested
Using supernatural advantages to help friends is only ethical if I'm willing to absorb all downside risk while limiting my upside gain.
That's the rule.
Save document.
Close laptop.
Pour whiskey.
Toast the empty apartment.
"To being the world's most conflicted investment manager."
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0