The early morning found them all back on the boardwalk—not to flee, but to breathe the cold sea air after the claustrophobic confinement of the casino and the courthouse. The boat plan had sunk. The wedding had evaporated. In their place remained an immense weariness and a strange sense of peace.
Barney, disappointed by the lack of nuptial action, had declared he would go "console his sorrow" at the nearest blackjack table. Ted and Robin followed, not so much for the game but to make sure he didn't compromise the return trip by selling the car.
That left Marshall, Lily, and Alyx alone facing the Atlantic—a dark, infinite mirror under a starless sky veiled by the casinos' light pollution.
The silence wasn't uncomfortable. It was the silence after a battle, when the smoke clears and you can see the field of ruins with clarity.
Marshall was the first to speak, his voice hoarse from weariness and pent-up emotion.
"This whole trip... it was nonsense, wasn't it?"
Lily, beside him, nodded without looking at him. "Yes. But necessary nonsense. Like sticking your finger in a socket to confirm it still gives you a shock."
Alyx, a couple of steps back, observing them from behind, smiled slightly. It was a good analogy.
"Alyx," Lily said, turning toward her. "What we talked about in the courthouse... thank you."
Marshall looked at Alyx, then at Lily, wondering what he had missed. Alyx simply nodded.
"No need to thank for the truth," she said. "You just have to listen to it."
Marshall took a deep breath, like someone preparing to dive into deep waters. "So... what's the truth now? For us? For the three of us?"
The question floated over the sound of the waves. It was the question they had been avoiding since the "permission to approach"—the concrete "what now?"
Lily crossed her arms, shielding herself from the wind. "I... I don't want a runaway wedding. And I don't think I want the big wedding with everyone watching either. Not yet." She looked at Marshall. "I want a relationship that works first. One that feels... fail-safe. Or at least has a good parachute system."
Marshall nodded. "I want that too... to trust and to be trusted. And that takes real time. Not a weekend in Atlantic City."
Both then looked at Alyx. It was her turn. The turn of the third corner of the triangle that refused to be just a supporting angle.
Alyx looked at the sea. She thought of her canvas, of the finished but empty building. She thought of the stored earring, no longer a prison but a museum artifact. She thought of Tracy, of her art classes, of the "one day at a time" mantra.
"I," she began, measuring each word, "don't want to be your safety net. I don't want to be your silence. I don't want to be the person you call when you hang up on each other." She paused. "But... I want to be in your lives in a new way. Where my love for the two of you isn't an obligation, or a job, or a consolation. Where it's... a daily choice."
The words were simple, but the meaning was monumental. She was outlining the terms of a new treaty—one where she had sovereignty over her own heart.
"And what does that look like?" asked Marshall with genuine curiosity, no defensiveness. "In practice?"
Alyx shrugged, a small gesture full of a newly discovered freedom. "Dinners for three. Sometimes stupid texts. Maybe, in time, a trip together. But also... time alone. Each with our own lives. Me with my paintings and my... memories. You two rebuilding your thing without me being the glue, without me being the constant witness."
Lily understood immediately. "You want to be... a friend. A very close friend. But not... not the pillar. Not the cornerstone."
"Exactly," said Alyx. "I want to be an arch in the structure, not the column that holds it up. I want your relationship as a couple to stand on its own. And my place to be a place, not an add-on. Not out of need."
It was a radical plan. It meant dismantling the dynamic that had defined them for years. It meant Marshall and Lily had to learn to be together without Alyx as a buffer, and Alyx had to learn to be with them without the role of caregiver.
"Sounds... terrifying," Marshall admitted.
"Sounds fair," said Lily, and her voice trembled not from fear but from something like respect. "It's how it always should have been."
Marshall extended his hand toward Alyx—not to help her, but to invite her to join them at the railing. A gesture of equals. Alyx hesitated for only an instant before approaching and placing her hands on the cold metal bar, forming a line of three facing the ocean.
"Step by step," said Marshall, looking at the horizon. "One day at a time."
"One day at a time," Lily repeated.
Alyx didn't repeat the phrase. She only nodded. Because for her, "one day at a time" wasn't a mantra; it was a fact. It was the only way she could live, knowing what she knew, remembering what she remembered. But for the first time, the idea that those days could include Marshall and Lily on new terms didn't fill her with anxiety. It filled her with a quiet curiosity.
The drive back to New York was silent but not heavy. Barney slept in the back seat. Ted drove, concentrated. Robin hummed a song. Marshall and Lily held hands, not with the urgency of before, but with a new calm.
Alyx looked out the window as the city approached like a cluster of promising lights. She felt the weight of her phone in her jacket pocket and knew that later, when she got to her apartment, there would be a message from Lily or Marshall. A "thanks for coming" or a "what a crazy trip, huh?" And she would reply, not because she had to, but because she wanted to.
Arriving at her building, as the others said goodbye with sleepy hugs, Lily approached Alyx.
"Coffee next week?" she asked. "Just us. To talk about... things that aren't failed weddings."
Alyx nodded. "Okay. I choose the place."
"Deal."
Going up to her apartment, Alyx didn't turn on the light immediately. Moonlight streamed through the window, illuminating the canvas. The building was finished—strong, tall, with its reflective windows. It no longer needed the scaffolding.
She walked toward it and, with a fine brush and a very diluted gold color, painted two small strokes in one of the top-floor windows. They weren't clear figures. They were just two spots of light, two warm presences looking from inside toward the same ocean she had contemplated hours before.
They weren't outside, reflected. They were inside, forming part of the structure, but not being the structure.
It was a good beginning. One day at a time. One heartbeat, one brushstroke, one text message at a time. The future, for once, didn't feel like a weight. It felt like a blank canvas, waiting for the colors that she, and only she, decided to mix.
If you enjoyed it, leave a Review and Power Stones.
✅ Early access to 10 new chapters
Join The Bro Code Level on Patreon
👉 https://[email protected]/cw/Day_bluefic
@=a
https://[email protected]/cw/Day_bluefic