The following days were a comedic nightmare for Ted. Moved by Marshall's new philosophy of total transparency, he was determined to uncover the truth. But Robin was a wall. Every attempt to pry was blocked with an increasingly creative evasion.
Alyx watched it all with growing amusement. She had begun to see the investigation as an absurd sideshow, a perfect distraction from her own demons.
One afternoon, she found Ted at the gym, pounding a punching bag with more desperation than technique.
"Mosby, you're going to dislocate your shoulder," she commented, adjusting the wraps on her own hands. "The bag isn't going to confess Robin's secret."
Ted stopped, panting. "I just don't get it, Alyx. Why won't she tell me? I'm her boyfriend. And Marshall says in a healthy relationship, there are no secrets."
Alyx let out a snort. Marshall Eriksen—the same one who, three months ago, couldn't get out of bed—was now the guru of relationships. "Fascinating." She approached the bag and delivered a quick, precise punch. "Transparency is good, Ted, but respect is better. If Robin doesn't want to talk, it's her right. It's not a crime to keep a piece of your past to yourself."
"But what if it's something serious? What if she's married?"
"And if she is?" Alyx looked directly at him. "Would it change anything? Would you stop loving her?"
Ted was speechless. The simple question disarmed him. Alyx smiled, not with sweetness, but with the irony of someone who knows the weight of secrets. "Exactly. So relax. Sometimes, the mystery itself is more interesting than the truth."
But Ted couldn't. The seed of doubt planted by Marshall and watered by Barney had taken root. So, following Marshall's advice to ask uncomfortable questions, he confronted Robin one night at her apartment.
The conversation was a disaster. Ted clumsily brought up the topic. Robin, evasive at first, finally dropped the bomb: Yes, she had been married. Young and dumb. Got married in a mall. He moved to Hong Kong, and she wanted to forget it.
Ted, with his heart shattered but feeling a strange relief at having an answer, promised to keep the secret.
And predictably, in the Mosby universe, he didn't last five minutes.
The next day at MacLaren's, under Lily the Commissioner's watchful eye, with Marshall and Barney present, he blurted out the truth. "Robin's married."
The effect was instant. Marshall smiled with satisfaction. "I knew it! Mall marriage! I win the bet!"
Barney rolled his eyes after the slap. "That proves nothing! She could be lying to cover up the porn!"
It was then that Lily, in her role as Commissioner, intervened with severity. "Ted, how dare you? Robin trusted you with a secret, and you spilled it like popcorn. That's a breach of trust."
Cornered, Ted tried to defend himself. "But it's the truth!"
"It was a test!" A voice exploded from the bar's entrance.
Everyone turned.
There stood Robin, arms crossed, eyes blazing with fury. "I was testing you, Ted. To see if you could keep a secret. And you failed. Spectacularly."
The silence was so thick you could cut it. Marshall paled. Barney smiled, seeing a new opportunity. Lily murmured a compassionate "oh, no." And Alyx, who had been observing the entire drama from a nearby table with a beer, let out a sigh that was half exasperation, half admiration for Robin's masterstroke.
"So... you were never married?" Ted managed to say, his world crumbling.
"No," Robin confirmed, her voice cold. "And now you'll never know what my real secret is. And it's a good one, by the way."
The fight that followed was epic. Accusations, shouts, the ghost of distrust dancing on the table. Marshall tried to mediate but was too busy calculating that his marriage theory had vanished. Barney seized the opportunity to declare that, with no marriage, his porn theory won by default.
And in the midst of the chaos, Barney produced his final triumph: a VHS tape. "I found it! The truth on tape! Courtesy of a gentleman from Malaysia with particular tastes!"
Robin paled. This time, the panic was real. Alyx, who had been enjoying the spectacle with comic detachment, grew serious seeing Robin's expression. She stood up and stepped between Barney and the VHS player.
"Barney, enough," she said, her voice low but loaded with an authority everyone had forgotten she possessed. "This has gone too far."
But Barney wouldn't stop. Ted, confused and hurt, also wanted answers. Marshall was torn. And Lily, as Commissioner, was paralyzed.
"No more hiding, Scherbatsky," said Barney, brushing past Alyx. "It's time the world met Robin Sparkles!"
The name fell like a brick. Sparkles. Alyx closed her eyes for a second.
It wasn't a vision; it was a deduction. Canada. Malls. Teenage embarrassment. Sparkles. The image was too ridiculous not to be true.
When the TV sprang to life with the synth of the 90s and the image of a teenage Robin in a sequined jacket, the group's reaction was perfect.
Ted, with silent awe.
Marshall, bursting with uncontrollable laughter.
Lily, a hand over her mouth, holding back giggles.
Barney, with absolute confusion and disappointment.
Alyx collapsed onto the sofa next to Robin, a silent but convulsive laughter shaking her body.
LET'S GO TO THE MALL, TODAY!
The song filled the room. Robin buried her face in her hands, but her shoulders shook with hysterical laughter and relief. The worst had happened, and it was so absurd it could only be liberating.
Alyx, between gasps, put an arm around Robin's shoulders. "The robot," she managed to say. "The robot is the best part."
When the video ended, the group was in a state of hilarious shock. Barney was the first to speak.
"This... this isn't porn," he mumbled, disappointed.
"It's worse!" Marshall shouted, still laughing. "It's Canadian bubblegum pop! I win! The bet was about the secret, and the secret is she was a pop star!"
"Wait!" Alyx intervened, wiping away tears of laughter. "As a neutral witness and the person who has probably enjoyed this spectacle the most, I propose a solution."
Everyone looked at her.
"Barney," she continued, "your theory was wrong in genre but correct in the core: fame and malls. Marshall, your theory was boring and now is false. Therefore, I declare a tie."
"A tie?" both protested.
"Yes," said Alyx, and a mischievous smile lit up her face. "And as punishment for turning Robin's life into a hunt and for making Ted break a confidence—fake or not—the sentence is this."
She turned to Lily. "Commissioner, do you approve?"
Lily, recovering, smiled broadly. "Absolutely. Pass sentence."
Alyx looked at Barney and Marshall. "You two, for the next 24 hours, must dress and act as if you were SparkleBoys. Sequins, baggy pants, and a 'Let's Go to the Mall' choreography that you will perform right here, tomorrow at this time."
The proposal was met with renewed laughter. Robin nodded, a real smile on her face. Ted, though still ashamed, couldn't help but smile at the idea.
Barney put on an expression of outraged dignity. Marshall, however, after a moment of shock, began to get excited.
"Can I be the robot?" he asked with genuine enthusiasm.
"Of course," said Alyx. "And Barney can be the lead girl. The role suits him."
The sentence was a resounding success.
The next day, seeing Barney Stinson covered in glitter with an expression of pure agony, awkwardly rapping about skateboards while Marshall acted as the robot with a tinfoil helmet, was the group therapy they didn't know they needed.
Alyx, seated between Lily and Robin, laughing until her ribs hurt, felt for the first time in months that the sound of her own laughter wasn't an intruder in her body, but a natural part of it.
She wasn't fixing, or analyzing, or surviving.
She was just laughing with her friends. With the broken fragments of her old family that were starting to resemble, against all odds, something new and resilient. Something that could withstand even the weight of a secret as ridiculous and glorious as Robin Sparkles.
If you enjoyed it, leave a Review and Power Stones.
✅ Early access to 10 new chapters
Join The Bro Code Level on Patreon
👉 https://[email protected]/cw/Day_bluefic
@=a