Cherreads

Chapter 7 - The Choice We Avoid

Choices don't always arrive loudly.

Sometimes, they wait.

They sit quietly between words not spoken, between glances held a second too long, between nights spent staring at the ceiling asking questions you're afraid to answer.

Lily felt that weight the entire morning.

She moved through the house on autopilot—making coffee, opening windows, straightening cushions that didn't need fixing. Mark had already left for work, rushing as usual, leaving behind the familiar echo of routine.

Ethan hadn't come downstairs yet.

She told herself not to think about that.

She failed.

Ethan stood in his room, backpack half-packed, phone buzzing with messages he ignored. Lily's question from earlier kept looping in his mind.

What comes next?

He'd given an honest answer.

Now he had to live with it.

He took a deep breath and left his room.

They met in the hallway.

Not planned.

Not avoidable.

"Morning," he said.

"Morning," she replied.

Something had changed.

Not the tension—it was still there—but the way they looked at each other. Less denial. More awareness.

"I'm heading out," Ethan said. "Might be late again."

She nodded. "Okay."

He took a step past her, then stopped.

"Lily… about yesterday—"

"I know," she said quickly. "We'll talk later."

Later.

The word carried more meaning than it should have.

The day moved painfully slow.

Ethan tried focusing on lectures, on notes, on conversations with classmates, but nothing stuck. His phone felt heavy in his pocket, like it carried something dangerous.

Across town, Lily sat alone in a café she used to love, staring into a cup of tea she hadn't touched. The noise around her faded into a dull hum.

She wasn't naïve.

She knew exactly what she was risking.

And yet, what scared her more wasn't the consequences.

It was the thought of waking up five years from now and wondering what if.

By the time she returned home, she'd made a decision.

Not a reckless one.

Just an honest one.

That evening, the house felt unusually quiet.

Ethan arrived home after sunset, shoulders tense, heart already racing. He found Lily in the living room, sitting upright on the couch, hands folded in her lap.

Waiting.

"We should talk," she said.

He nodded. "Yeah."

She gestured to the armchair across from her. "Sit."

He did.

The distance between them felt deliberate—but temporary.

"I don't want to keep pretending," Lily began. "Not to you. Not to myself."

Ethan listened, every muscle tight.

"This thing between us," she continued, "it didn't start because we wanted trouble. It just… happened."

"Yes," he said quietly.

"But acknowledging it doesn't mean acting on it," she added. "At least not without thinking."

"I agree," he said.

She studied him carefully. "Do you?"

"Yes," he replied honestly. "Because if we rush this, we'll regret it. And if we ignore it… we'll resent it."

Her breath caught slightly.

"That's exactly how it feels," she said.

They sat there, both realizing something important.

They weren't fighting temptation.

They were negotiating truth.

"I need to say this clearly," Lily said. "Nothing physical. Not now. Maybe not ever."

Ethan didn't flinch.

"Okay."

"But," she added, her voice softer now, "I also can't keep acting like you don't matter to me."

His chest tightened. "You matter to me too."

She closed her eyes briefly, grounding herself.

"So here's what I'm asking," she said. "Honesty. No secrets. No pretending. If this gets too much… we say it out loud."

"And then?" he asked.

"Then we decide again."

He nodded slowly. "I can do that."

They both knew it wasn't a solution.

It was a truce.

Days passed with a strange new rhythm.

They didn't pull away anymore—but they didn't cross lines either. Conversations were more open, quieter, heavier with meaning.

They talked about fears. About regrets. About paths they never thought they'd walk.

Sometimes they laughed.

Sometimes silence sat between them, thick but not uncomfortable.

Mark noticed the change.

Not the reason—just the shift.

"You two seem closer," he remarked one evening casually. "That's good. Nice to see the house feel alive."

Lily smiled. Ethan nodded.

Neither spoke.

One night, everything nearly fell apart.

It started small.

A storm rolled in unexpectedly, rain hammering against the windows, thunder shaking the walls. The power flickered once… twice… then went out.

The house plunged into darkness.

"Great," Lily muttered from the hallway.

Ethan grabbed a candle from the drawer, lighting it carefully. The soft glow filled the living room with familiar shadows.

They stood too close.

Neither moved away.

Thunder cracked loudly, closer than before. Lily flinched instinctively.

Without thinking, Ethan reached out.

His hand stopped inches from her arm.

He froze.

She looked at him.

The moment stretched.

"Ethan…" she whispered.

"I know," he said hoarsely. "I won't."

She swallowed, eyes shining.

"I didn't ask you to stop," she admitted.

The truth hung heavy between them.

Slowly, carefully, he lowered his hand—but didn't leave.

"This is exactly why I'm scared," she said. "Because I don't know how long I can keep choosing restraint."

He met her gaze. "Then tell me when it's too much."

She nodded.

The storm raged outside.

Inside, they stood still, barely breathing.

Later that night, Ethan lay awake, heart pounding.

He'd come closer than ever.

Not physically—but emotionally.

And that scared him more.

Across the hall, Lily sat by her window, watching rain blur the world outside.

She pressed her palm to the glass, whispering to no one—

"I'm already in too deep."

The next morning brought unexpected news.

Ethan received an email from college—an opportunity for a paid internship starting soon. Good experience. Long hours.

He read it twice.

Then went downstairs.

"Lily," he said, holding out his phone. "I got an internship offer."

Her eyes widened. "That's great."

"It is," he said. "But it'll mean less time at home."

She nodded slowly.

Something twisted in her chest.

"That might be good," she said carefully.

"For us," he added.

"Yes."

But neither of them sounded convinced.

Because distance had already proven one thing—

It didn't erase feelings.

It sharpened them.

And now, standing at the edge of a new phase, they both understood the truth they'd been avoiding since the beginning.

This wasn't just about temptation anymore.

It was about choice.

And the hardest part wasn't deciding what they wanted—

It was deciding what they were willing to lose.

End of Chapter 7

More Chapters