Chapter 4: The New Scott McCall
[Beacon Hills High School — Monday, September 19, 2011, 7:52 AM]
The fly changed everything.
Jackson was at his locker pulling out a chemistry textbook when he caught it — three lockers down, Scott McCall's hand shooting out sideways with the precision of a striking snake. His fingers closed around something. He opened his palm. A housefly sat there, stunned and buzzing, and Scott stared at it like it had just spoken to him in Mandarin.
Stiles Stilinski materialized at Scott's elbow, eyes wide, mouth already running. "Dude. Dude, did you just — how did you — what was—"
"I don't know." Scott's voice was quiet. Confused. He shook the fly loose and wiped his hand on his jeans. His head kept turning — tracking sounds, Jackson guessed. Sounds that a normal sixteen-year-old shouldn't be able to hear. His nostrils flared every few seconds, processing input that had no frame of reference.
Jackson closed his locker. The old Jackson — the real Jackson — would have shouldered past Scott with a comment about reflexes or a crack about steroids. The hallway expected it. Three guys from the lacrosse team were watching from across the corridor, waiting for the show.
Jackson walked past. "McCall," he said. Neutral. A nod, nothing more. The same nod you'd give anyone you recognized but didn't care about.
Scott blinked. Stiles' mouth stopped moving for the first time in recorded history. They watched him go, and Jackson could almost hear the recalculation happening — Jackson Whittemore just acknowledged Scott McCall without malice. What dimension is this?
Danny fell into step beside him before he reached the stairwell. "That was weird."
"What was."
"You. Walking past McCall without saying something awful. Since when are you the bigger person?"
"Since today." Jackson adjusted his backpack strap. "He's on the team. I don't need to make him hate me before the season starts."
Danny considered this. His eyes did the thing they'd been doing since last week — the slight narrowing, the analytical pause, the moment where Danny Mahealani processed information and filed it somewhere Jackson couldn't access.
"Okay," Danny said. Not agreement. Acknowledgment.
They walked to first period, and Jackson let Danny carry the conversation about a coding assignment he'd already forgotten, and behind them Scott McCall stood at his locker hearing things and smelling things and beginning the long process of not understanding what he'd become.
---
[Beacon Hills High — Front Office, 10:15 AM]
Jackson saw Allison Argent for the first time through the glass panel in the principal's office door.
She was sitting in the chair across from the administrative assistant, dark hair pulled back, filling out enrollment paperwork with the calm competence of someone who'd done this before. Multiple schools. Multiple fresh starts. The Argent family moved often — hunters followed the work, and the work followed the supernatural, and the supernatural was about to give Beacon Hills the kind of attention that drew families like the Argents from across the country.
She looked up as if she could sense his gaze. Brown eyes, direct, a polite half-smile that said I'm new, be nice. Jackson returned the look without expression and kept walking.
Allison Argent. Chris Argent's daughter. Kate Argent's niece. Future hunter, future love interest for Scott McCall, future dead girl if the timeline runs hot.
He passed the counselor's office, turned the corner, and leaned against the wall for three seconds with his eyes closed.
She's seventeen. She doesn't know what her family does. She doesn't know her aunt burned a house full of people. She likes archery and French and she's going to fall in love with a boy who turns into a werewolf on the full moon, and I could walk into that office right now and tell her everything and save her from all of it.
And ruin everything. The Argents needed to be in Beacon Hills. Chris Argent was the only hunter Jackson could eventually trust — the man's code was real, his conscience was operational, and he'd become an ally in every version of this story that Jackson remembered. Allison needed to meet Scott. That relationship was load-bearing; it turned Scott from a scared kid into a leader.
Jackson opened his eyes and pushed off the wall. Two students passed, arguing about a Spanish assignment. The hallway smelled like floor wax and cheap perfume. Normal school sounds — locker slams, laughter, a teacher's muffled voice through a closed door.
He went to third period and sat in the back row and took notes on cellular biology while Allison Argent finished her paperwork three hallways away and Scott McCall's superhuman hearing picked up a heartbeat across the building that would define his entire life.
Let it play out.
The words were becoming a reflex. A mantra. The most passive sentence in the English language, and Jackson was starting to hate it.
---
[Hale House Ruins — 4:47 PM]
The Hale house was worse than television suggested.
On screen, the burned shell of the Hale family home read as atmospheric — blue-tinted, gothic, a mood setter for Derek's tragic backstory. In the golden hour of a September afternoon, with real sunlight picking out the blackened rafters and the collapsed second floor and the weeds pushing through what used to be a foundation, it read as something else entirely.
It read as a crime scene. A mass grave disguised as an architectural casualty.
Jackson parked the Porsche on the dirt access road and sat for a moment. The preserve surrounded the property on three sides — dense, shadowed even in daylight, the kind of forest that swallowed sound. Birds were singing. The disconnect between birdsong and burned ruins made his teeth ache.
The folder was on the passenger seat. He'd spent Sunday building it — public records from the Beacon Hills fire department, insurance filings, newspaper clippings from the Hale fire six years ago, property records showing the land transfer after the deaths. All of it available through county databases that any motivated person with an internet connection could find.
What made the folder valuable wasn't the information. It was the arrangement. Jackson had organized it chronologically, annotated the inconsistencies in the fire marshal's report, highlighted the accelerant findings that should have triggered an arson investigation, and flagged the three-week gap between the fire and the official closing of the case. The kind of analysis that screamed someone looked the other way.
Inside the folder, on a plain notecard, he'd written: Someone should have looked harder. — J.W.
He got out of the car. The air tasted like pine sap and old char — six years of rain hadn't washed the smoke out of the wood. His shoes crunched on gravel, then on the scorched earth of the front path. The porch was half-collapsed, the planks bowing under their own weight.
Jackson set the folder on the porch railing, tucked securely between two posts where wind wouldn't take it. He straightened. Stepped back.
The prickle on the back of his neck was immediate and unmistakable. Not supernatural — animal. The sensation of being watched by something that could close the distance before he finished turning around.
Derek's here. He's been here the whole time.
Jackson didn't turn. Didn't search the tree line. He walked back to the Porsche at a normal pace, got in, started the engine, and pulled away. In the rearview mirror, the house sat in its clearing like a rotten tooth, and no one emerged from the trees.
But the folder was gone before he reached the main road. He checked. It was gone.
---
[Whittemore Residence — 6:30 PM]
Dinner was roasted vegetables and salmon. Margaret had left a note: At book club. Plate in oven. Dad home late. xo
Jackson ate standing at the counter — a habit from his previous life he hadn't managed to break and didn't bother trying. The salmon was overcooked by two minutes, the broccoli was perfect, and he ate all of it because Jackson Whittemore's body burned through calories at a rate that demanded constant fuel, especially with the 5 AM gym sessions he'd been maintaining.
His phone buzzed twice during dinner. Lydia: a photo of homecoming decorations with the caption thoughts? Danny: a link to a YouTube video of a lacrosse highlight reel with no comment attached.
He answered Lydia (looks good) and opened Danny's video and watched a goalkeeper execute a save that defied physics and thought about Scott McCall catching a fly without looking.
After dinner, he washed his plate, dried it, put it away. Poured a glass of water. Stood at the kitchen window and looked out at the backyard, where the Whittemores' perfectly maintained lawn stretched to a fence line bordered by rosebushes.
A nice life. This is a genuinely nice life. Good food, warm house, parents who leave notes with 'xo' at the end. The original Jackson threw this away chasing validation from strangers.
The thought came without bitterness. Just observation. Jackson Whittemore's life — the one that had existed before a stranger moved in — had been built on a rotten foundation of abandonment anxiety and performative dominance. But the architecture around it was solid. The parents cared. The house was safe. The resources were abundant.
Jackson could work with this. He was working with it.
He finished the water and went upstairs to the bedroom. Opened the laptop. Pulled up the encrypted file — LACROSSE STATS 2011 — and updated it. Sept 19. Allison enrolled. Scott's symptoms visible. Folder delivered to DH property. No direct contact. Camaro not visible at house but folder retrieved within 5 minutes of departure.
He closed the laptop and picked up the car keys.
Eight PM. The September sky was purple and orange through the bedroom window, and somewhere in Beacon Hills Derek Hale was reading a folder that a stranger had left on his dead family's porch, and somewhere else Scott McCall was lying in bed listening to conversations three houses away, and somewhere else Allison Argent was unpacking boxes in a new bedroom in a new town near a preserve full of things her family had been hunting for generations.
Jackson drove to the gym. Push-ups, pull-ups, core work, heavy bag. An hour and a half of reshaping a body that wasn't built for what was coming. His knuckles split on the fourth round with the bag — old wraps, bad angle — and he taped them in the locker room and drove home with blood seeping through the gauze.
The rearview mirror caught headlights two blocks behind him. A black Camaro, distinctive even in the dark, pulling out of a side road and following at a distance that was too careful to be coincidence.
Jackson watched it for three blocks. At the fourth intersection, the Camaro turned right and disappeared.
Derek Hale had read the folder. And now Derek Hale knew who'd left it.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0