Cherreads

Chapter 296 - Provocation (Bonus Chapter)

The charcoal in the fireplace gave a soft pop, and a few orange sparks leapt up in the hushed sitting room before dying away.

[I Know U]

Three words, pieced together from printed letters of different sizes and typefaces, glared out from the cheap sheet of paper.

After a brief moment of shock, the drowsiness drained from Charlotte's gray-blue eyes.

In its place came the cool, sharp focus of a detective.

"Looks like the Phantom Thief's little visit left behind some things it shouldn't have."

She gave a cold laugh, but there wasn't a trace of panic in it.

She held the note up to the yellow halo of the gas lamp and studied the grain of the paper and the traces of the paste-up.

"The paper is the cheap pulp stock you can find anywhere. No watermark, no family crest, nothing to trace.

The letters were cut from newspapers. The edges are very clean, so it wasn't scissors but an extremely sharp paper knife.

The sources are mixed, too. This 'I' is oversized with heavy ink, so it's the headline typeface from the front page of The Times.

But 'Know' has rough edges. That's clearly from the cheap Daily Telegraph.

As for the adhesive..."

The girl lowered her head, brought her nose close to the paper and sniffed, her brows drawing together.

"The adhesive is plain potato starch, the sort of thing sold on every street corner.

So the sender has no intention of revealing who he is."

She tossed the note onto the tea table and folded her arms. Her tone was mocking, but an unmistakable gravity sat between her brows.

"Whoever sent this has a very keen nose for information. He used clippings instead of handwriting so I couldn't trace him through the script or the ink."

Charlotte paused, then turned to Russell.

"Did you take your mask off in front of Adrian?"

"Of course not," Russell shot back. "No matter how much I crave a thrill, I'm not stupid enough to pull a stunt like that.

Besides," he went on, "if it really were Adrian, why would the old man bother writing a threatening letter? If he knew who I was, he'd have no reason to keep fearing Mary."

"True." Charlotte pinched the bridge of her nose. "Apart from him, who else have you been exposed to? Benson Morstan?"

"He doesn't even know when I visited his house."

Russell shook his head again.

Seeing him so unruffled, calm as a man watching a mountain collapse in front of him, Charlotte felt the faint worry in her chest finally ease.

She sat down on the sofa, pressed her palms together beneath her chin, and began to work it through.

"The sender didn't mention the name Moriarty directly, and there's no blackmail sum or demand attached. Just three words: [I know who you are].

That means his goal isn't to extort you. He's testing your reaction. It's a classic psychological game.

It's also a provocation."

Charlotte paced beside the tea table, her silk robe swaying with each step.

"If you'd panicked and bolted the moment you got this letter, or rushed to move your assets, or even contacted Mary, you'd be confessing without a word. You'd expose the link between you two and hand him your weak spot with your own hands."

"A psychological game, huh..." Russell leaned back in his chair, his long fingers tapping lightly on the arm of the sofa.

"Last night in Adrian's study, was anyone else there besides you and the old man?"

Charlotte suddenly thought of something else and asked.

"What if the old fox secretly arranged a stenographer or a reporter?"

"A reporter?" Russell raised an eyebrow. "I was in the shadows at the time. There really is a hidden door on the side of his study.

I didn't bother to expose it, but there was definitely someone hiding in that room."

"That fits." The corners of Charlotte's mouth curled up, as though proud of having found a direction.

"That old fox Adrian was willing to pay a fortune to buy you off, so of course he'd prepare a second plan.

Whatever the outcome, the paparazzo hiding in the dark would record your conversation and pick it apart for something to use as a weapon in the press."

She looked at Russell again. "You didn't say anything that could be over-interpreted or used against you, did you?"

"Of course not. I knew someone was eavesdropping," Russell said. "So from start to finish, I made it clear that I had done all of this on my own. I never even mentioned Mary's name."

Charlotte gave a slight nod, but her gaze only grew sharper.

"Then we can pretty much rule out Benson and Adrian.

If the reporter has nothing on you, then nobody could have confirmed your identity from a few ambiguous lines of conversation."

She frowned. "Which means he reached his conclusion from some other angle. What angle?"

The girl lifted her head and looked toward the tabletop, though her eyes weren't focused on it at all.

Charlotte had slipped into a trance. Her hands rose slowly, her slender fingertips plucking at the air as if she were sorting through documents.

Russell didn't interrupt. He picked up his cup of black tea, now lukewarm, settled back on the sofa, and quietly enjoyed the sight of the great detective entering her mind palace.

The yellow firelight danced across Charlotte's pale face, gilding her focused, sharp profile with a soft glow like something out of a film.

Her head tilted slightly back, her long lashes casting faint shadows beneath her eyes. Her slender fingers swept and rearranged in the empty air, as though she were leafing through a case file only she could see.

"Not physical evidence from the scene, and not a direct slip of the tongue..."

Charlotte murmured, her speech quickening, calculation glinting in her gray-blue eyes.

"Since we've excluded fools like Adrian and Benson, who are stuck inside the game, this person must be standing somewhere higher.

He must command an enormous intelligence network, one that takes in everything that happens in London.

And he appears at precisely this moment. Not earlier, not later, but right after Benson Morstan and Adrian Morstan have both fallen.

That means he's closely tied to the Morstan family, and he's not a native Londoner."

Charlotte's eyes snapped open. Her hands closed in the air as if gathering something up, and she turned to Russell, her gaze burning.

"How can you be sure of that?" Russell asked.

"If he were really a native Londoner, he couldn't have failed to show up the moment Arthur Morstan was taken to the hospital.

If he'd really come for the Morstan fortune, that was the perfect moment.

All he had to do was raise a plausible suspicion and plant a seed in Scotland Yard's mind, and everything would have played out differently.

But he didn't. That means by the time he got his information, the case had already been closed."

Charlotte said.

"Then how did he conclude that I'm Moriarty?" Russell asked.

"Simple. Subtraction," Charlotte said.

"Subtraction?" Russell raised an eyebrow, throwing out the question at just the right moment.

"Exactly. Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."

Charlotte nodded.

"After arriving in London, this person didn't show his face right away. He hid in the shadows.

We don't know when he came, but suppose he's already been in London for some time.

During that time, he kept gathering information through his own channels.

To him, the greatest threat now is naturally Moriarty, so every piece of intelligence he collected started from Moriarty.

And when it comes to intelligence about Moriarty... Fleet Street has as much as anyone could want."

The girl paused and shot Russell a glance.

"And we have a certain someone to thank for that, someone who loves feeding Fleet Street its circulation numbers."

"A man's gotta eat..." Russell coughed awkwardly.

"I may make the papers a lot, but that doesn't prove I'm connected to him."

"Which is why that intelligence has to be pared down further."

Charlotte continued her analysis.

"Apart from you, who else was he after? Or rather, who was he coming for in the first place?"

"Mary."

"Right. Mary," Charlotte said with a nod.

"So once he realized the news about Moriarty couldn't give him any useful leads, naturally he'd shift his attention.

If there's no progress on the Moriarty side for now, what about Mary?"

Charlotte stood and headed for the door.

Russell hesitated briefly, then followed right behind her.

The two left Russell's room and went straight to Charlotte's own sitting room, a place she hadn't visited in a long time.

She hadn't even bothered to light the fireplace in there.

Russell crouched down and lit it, then went over to put the water on to boil.

Charlotte pulled out the evidence board, wiped everything off it, picked up a pen, and began to write and sketch.

"Mary." She wrote Mary's name on the board and drew several arrows from it.

"If you want to investigate a person, you start with their background and their relationships.

Her background we can set aside for now. I don't think he's capable of digging out the fact that she's The Professor. Otherwise he wouldn't need to come to you at all."

"So the key is her relationships," Russell said.

"Yes, her relationships." As she spoke, Charlotte rapidly wrote a string of other names beside Mary's.

"This Elizabeth, and this Helena, and Isabella. Who are these three?" Russell asked curiously.

"I've never heard of them."

"Neither have I, because they don't matter," Charlotte said. "Those names stand for the people Mary deals with in her everyday disguise."

She picked up the pen and ruthlessly struck through those names, then circled the only two left.

"The only people who really matter are two: Russell Watson and Charlotte Holmes."

Charlotte said.

"To be precise, really only you matter. I'm incidental. I got dragged in because of you."

Charlotte jabbed the tip of her pen twice against [Russell Watson].

"Like I said, every hypothesis has to be built around the core threat, [Moriarty].

When that person found no breakthrough in the vast sea of Phantom Thief rumors, all of it hearsay, he would inevitably change tack.

He'd study Mary's social circle, trying to find the link that ties her to the Phantom Thief.

And in that carefully filtered network, you, Russell Watson, stand out like a searchlight in the dead of night."

"Am I really that flashy?"

Russell rubbed his nose and poured the freshly boiled water into the teapot. The fragrance of black tea began to drift through the chilly sitting room.

"What exactly do you misunderstand about a record that could shake Buckingham Palace?"

Charlotte turned around and rolled her eyes at him, her pen tracing an arc through the air.

"An orphan with no background, who within a few short months of entering Imperial College manages to get cozy with both the great detective Holmes and London high society's brightest flower, Mary.

Do you think the students at Imperial College are just decoration? Even if they never read the papers, can't they see you and Mary together on campus?"

At this, the girl's tone soured despite herself, and her grip on the pen tightened, as if she were venting some grievance.

"Tell that to anyone on the streets of London, and apart from envy and jealousy, they'll all have the very same thought—"

"'Why him?'" Russell finished.

"Good, at least you know your place," Charlotte huffed.

"Why can a poor student move so easily between two such mountains?

Why would Mycroft, who is practically the British Government itself, turn a blind eye to something that could pass for a scandal? Why hasn't a single newspaper dared to report it?"

Charlotte stared at Russell as if she were the mysterious sender herself, interrogating him.

"Unless..."

"Unless Russell Watson himself holds a trump card equal to theirs, one strong enough that even Mycroft would fear it or want to use it."

Russell came over carrying two cups of hot tea and took up her thread naturally.

He handed one cup to the girl, and his gaze fell on the evidence board, now freshly covered in writing.

"He's seen my photograph, and that paparazzo has seen what Moriarty looks like."

"Under normal circumstances, those conditions carry no weight. But once a preconception takes hold, every coincidence starts to glare."

Charlotte took the cup and sipped.

"And if those guesses gave him enough grounds for suspicion, then everything that happened afterward kept stacking evidence onto it, piece after piece."

The girl's pen moved slowly downward and wrote a new name in an empty space.

Philip Morstan.

"The South Bank warehouse is sealed and Philip is arrested."

Charlotte said.

"Why did Lestrade suddenly lead a team to seal the South Bank warehouse? Because he received a tip that someone was hiding weapons there.

So who tipped him off? Moriarty, naturally.

Why would Moriarty play the thief who cries 'stop thief' and stash weapons in the warehouse Philip Morstan managed?

And on the very night Benson was going to have Philip cut off supplies to the East End factories?

And why, just as Philip Morstan was about to be taken away for treason, did I turn up?"

Charlotte pointed at herself.

"I cleared Philip of the treason charge, but pinned a new one on him, so that he went to prison in a way that wouldn't drag down the whole Morstan family.

If that can be explained by a detective's sense of justice, then here comes the real problem.

How did I know?"

Charlotte looked at Russell.

"Who told me?

In all of London, besides Moriarty, Lestrade and Mary, there isn't a fourth person who knew weapons were hidden in the South Bank warehouse.

Lestrade already had his evidence, so he had no need to call me in to help. The same goes for Mary.

Which leaves only Moriarty as the one who could have told me.

And how would he have told me? As it happens, I have a roommate, and his name is Russell Watson."

Charlotte drew a big circle on the evidence board, looping from the name Moriarty back around to Russell's.

"What a surprising coincidence, isn't it?"

____

Gift for Everyone: Once we hit 10 Powerstones, I'll release +1 bonus chapter

________________________________________

If you want more chapters, please consider supporting my page on (P). with 50 advanced chapters available on (P)

👻 Join the crew by searching Leanzin on (P). You know the spot! 😉

More Chapters