Cherreads

Chapter 140 - Chapter 140: The Argument

The implication was deliberate.

By Daisy's estimate, those critical variables in the Arc Reactor weren't fully understood by anyone—not Tony Stark, and probably not Howard Stark either. The most likely explanation was that Howard had simply copied down a few readings from the Tesseract and incorporated them directly into the reactor's design. As for where those numbers came from, what formula generated them, or what physical principle they obeyed—nobody actually knew.

She suspected Howard Stark had been much like his son in temperament. Too proud to let posterity think he'd given up on understanding his own work. So he'd left Tony a blueprint—without the explanation behind it.

"What you're doing is pure imitation. You've completely abandoned any spirit of scientific inquiry," Stark said, still pushing.

"Imitation? Scientific inquiry?" Daisy scoffed. "You want to talk about that? Go tear up every existing dataset and derive everything from first principles. Build something entirely new. What you've actually done is iterate on an inherited foundation, same as everyone else who's ever touched this. Don't dress that up as something nobler than it is."

"I'll build a completely new reactor," Stark said, quiet and even. "When I do, you'll see the gap between us clearly enough."

Daisy made a short sound—neither agreement nor dismissal—and let it sit.

They'd run out of things to say to each other. The film continued.

A moment later, Stark spoke again. "Eight soldiers going to rescue one. Why would you make a film about that? Those eight had families too. Was it worth it?"

"It's a story about redemption," Daisy answered, less from thought than from having lived with the film long enough that the words came automatically. "If you look at the outcome—Ryan was saved. That makes it worth it. And from Miller's perspective, it was worth it for him too."

Before Afghanistan, the version of Tony Stark who cycled through magazine cover shoots and lived on applause would have dismissed that kind of sentiment out of hand. But not anymore.

He'd started mapping himself onto it. Rhodes had kept everything locked down tight, and the official Kandahar statement had been "terrorist incident," but the pattern of evidence told a different story. Stark had pieced together enough to know that during the weeks he was missing, something significant had happened at that base—civilians and soldiers had died.

Had they died trying to get him back? He wasn't certain. But the weight of that possibility had settled somewhere he couldn't shift it.

And then the film reached its end. Lieutenant Miller lay dying, and with what was left of him, he told Ryan to live—to make all of it mean something.

Stark went quiet. Maybe he was thinking about Yinsen. Maybe about Kandahar. He lost the will to say anything, stood, and walked out of the theater before the credits rolled.

Did the film shake something loose in him? Daisy scratched her head. She'd never once considered Stark when they made this film—and somehow it had landed squarely in the middle of his life.

The screening ended. The applause was thin and scattered, fading quickly.

"Doesn't look like the response was great." Happy's face had drained of color. First solo directorial effort. The budget had been raided more than once—still a nine-figure production in the end. The pressure had been crushing. Now, scanning the room at lukewarm reactions, he felt his stomach sink.

Daisy talked him down. Profit wasn't the point. Visibility and reputation were.

Obama had been leveraging the Kandahar situation to build momentum for his Afghan withdrawal platform. A film that showed war's cost from the ground up had found a lane in that conversation—even if the audience at the premiere hadn't fully registered it yet.

The screening itself produced no real buzz. Most of the press left with the same read: excellent cinematography, layered visual composition, technically strong—but the central message was thorny. Eight elite soldiers sacrificed for one ordinary man. Did that math work? Was it defensible?

The critics weren't hostile, exactly. Just unconvinced. And they weren't even being careful out of principle—they were being careful because a significant portion of American veterans were still struggling with severe PTSD. Say the wrong thing, and the consequences could be irreversible.

Getting wide theatrical distribution was harder this time around. Using S.H.I.E.L.D.'s name to pressure theater owners had worked once. Doing it again would make permanent enemies.

Fortunately, Daisy had hitched Skye Entertainment's wagon to the Democratic Party, and the film's themes aligned naturally with Obama's withdrawal campaign. Support came from that wing without much pushing.

Money didn't pick sides—but the people controlling it did, or at least performed as though they did. Distribution started expanding.

It wasn't the saturation Jurassic Park had achieved, but backed by Democratic goodwill, the film rolled out nationally. Internationally, some markets approved it immediately. Others were still deciding.

Most audiences walked in expecting a triumphalist war movie—the kind where American soldiers were untouchable, mowing down hundreds of enemies in clean, satisfying sequences.

They got something else entirely.

Right from the opening sequence, the Americans were being slaughtered. And they never really recovered from it. And then, at the end, Captain Miller—the protagonist—died. Not in a blaze of glory. No dramatic last stand, no final heroic moment. He just got shot. Twice. And fell.

A quiet death. Nothing cinematic about it.

Audiences were not happy. The debates rolled in. Praise was rare. Complaints were loud.

Ordinary people reacting online, Daisy thought. Nothing worth worrying about.

Because the military came out in support.

Bases around the world—and stateside veterans still working through the aftermath of service—sent their endorsements from every direction.

Whatever philosophical questions the film raised, whatever the real-world calculus behind those orders—depicting ordinary soldiers as lives worth saving rather than expendable assets on a board resonated deeply in a climate where recruitment was already an uphill climb.

The military didn't wade into politics officially. But certain senior figures made their approval unmistakable. Saving Private Ryan, they said, deserved a place alongside the propaganda shorts Captain America had filmed during World War II.

With the current administration and both presidential candidates all scrambling for military endorsement, none of them were about to push back. High-level consensus formed quickly: regardless of which party took power next, senators still needed the public willing to fight wars. The film was pushed on a global scale.

Ordinary audiences were baffled. The more they complained, the wider the release got?

Something felt orchestrated about this.

Whether it was or wasn't, Daisy stayed on her own schedule. The fractures she'd been quietly widening inside S.H.I.E.L.D.'s HYDRA network kept spreading.

John Garrett, the film's lead actor, was suddenly drawing more public attention than he'd ever anticipated.

More Chapters