Cherreads

Chapter 66 - Chapter 65The Letter Nobody Was Supposed to Read

Isle POV

Three days passed after the conversation in the storage room.

Three quiet days.

Three peaceful days.

---

The kind of peace that feels temporary.

---

Nobody argued.

Nobody raised their voice.

Nobody tried to force a decision.

---

Yet beneath that calm surface...

something felt unfinished.

---

Like a book missing its final chapters.

---

Or a conversation interrupted halfway through.

---

I couldn't explain it.

---

But I felt it everywhere.

In the hallways.

At dinner.

In the way Mian sometimes stared out windows when she thought nobody was looking.

---

Something was changing.

---

And all of us knew it.

---

Mian POV

Sleep had become difficult.

---

Not because of nightmares.

---

Because of memories.

---

Too many memories.

---

Too many old versions of herself suddenly returning.

---

The frightened child.

The lonely teenager.

The young woman who built entire futures around promises.

---

Versions she thought she had left behind.

---

But lately...

they seemed determined to remind her they still existed.

---

Which was unfortunate.

---

Because Mian hated feeling vulnerable.

---

And memories were vulnerability in its purest form.

---

Flashback — Age Fifteen

The rain had been falling all afternoon.

---

The house was quiet.

---

Too quiet.

---

One of those days when everyone seemed busy with their own lives.

---

Except Mian.

---

She had spent hours alone in her room.

Reading.

Writing.

Thinking.

---

Mostly thinking.

---

At fifteen she already had a habit of thinking too much.

---

And that afternoon she wrote a letter.

---

A letter nobody was supposed to read.

---

A letter she never intended to send.

---

A letter she eventually hid inside an old book.

Then forgot about.

---

Or at least convinced herself she had forgotten.

---

Present Day — Isle POV

I discovered it by accident.

---

Which, looking back, seemed to be how every important discovery in my life happened.

---

I was helping reorganize the library.

---

A task nobody wanted.

---

Including me.

---

Dust covered everything.

---

Books were stacked everywhere.

---

At one point I pulled an old novel from the shelf.

---

Something slipped out.

---

A folded piece of paper.

---

Yellowed with age.

---

I almost ignored it.

---

Almost.

---

Then I noticed the handwriting.

---

Mian's.

---

My stomach tightened.

---

Immediately I knew I shouldn't read it.

---

Which only made me more curious.

---

Isle POV

For several minutes I simply stared at it.

---

Debating.

---

Arguing with myself.

---

Knowing it was private.

Knowing it was wrong.

---

Yet unable to put it down.

---

Finally...

I unfolded it.

---

And instantly wished I hadn't.

---

Not because it contained something terrible.

---

Because it contained something heartbreaking.

---

The Letter

Dear Isle,

---

Today you spent three hours teaching me how to draw birds.

---

You are terrible at drawing birds.

---

I didn't tell you because you looked very proud of yourself.

---

I think every bird you drew looked like a potato with wings.

---

But I liked spending time with you anyway.

---

A small laugh escaped me despite myself.

---

The younger Mian sounded surprisingly funny.

---

I kept reading.

---

Sometimes I think you're the only person who notices when I'm unhappy.

---

That sounds dramatic.

---

Maybe it is dramatic.

---

But it's true.

---

My smile slowly faded.

---

The handwriting changed slightly lower down.

---

Becoming messier.

---

More emotional.

---

Everyone says family takes time.

---

But I don't know how much time it's supposed to take.

---

Some days I still feel like a visitor.

---

Some days I feel like I belong.

---

The days I feel like I belong are usually the days you're around.

---

The words blurred.

---

Not because I couldn't read them.

---

Because suddenly I understood exactly how lonely she had been.

---

Mian POV

She found Isle in the library twenty minutes later.

---

And immediately knew.

---

Not because Isle looked guilty.

---

Because she was holding the letter.

---

The old letter.

---

The one Mian thought had disappeared years ago.

---

For a second her heart stopped.

---

Not from anger.

---

From panic.

---

Pure instinctive panic.

---

Mian

"Where did you find that?"

---

The question came out sharper than intended.

---

Isle looked up immediately.

---

And guilt flashed across her face.

---

Isle

"It fell out of a book."

---

Silence.

---

Neither moved.

---

Neither spoke.

---

The atmosphere shifted instantly.

---

Heavy.

---

Uncomfortable.

---

Mian POV

Of all the things Isle could have discovered...

it had to be that.

---

Not the photographs.

Not old memories.

---

The letter.

---

The one written before she learned how dangerous honesty could be.

---

Isle POV

"I'm sorry."

---

The apology came immediately.

---

"I know I shouldn't have read it."

---

Mian closed her eyes briefly.

---

Then sighed.

---

The anger never arrived.

---

Only exhaustion.

---

Mian

"No."

---

A pause.

---

"You probably shouldn't have."

---

Another pause.

---

"But you already did."

---

The answer surprised me.

---

Because she wasn't accusing me.

---

She simply sounded tired.

---

Mian POV

There was no point pretending.

---

No point demanding explanations.

---

The letter existed.

Isle had read it.

---

Nothing could change that.

---

So instead she sat down.

---

Across from Isle.

---

Just as she had during their previous conversation.

---

And waited.

---

Isle POV

The silence stretched.

---

Eventually I looked down at the paper again.

---

One final section remained.

---

The final paragraph.

---

The one I hadn't been brave enough to read aloud.

---

My voice came quietly.

---

Isle

"You wrote..."

---

I swallowed.

---

"I'm scared that one day you'll stop choosing me."

---

Silence.

---

Absolute silence.

---

The words echoed through the room.

---

Even years later.

---

Even written by a teenager.

---

They carried pain.

---

Mian POV

She remembered writing that sentence.

---

Remembered staring at it for nearly an hour afterward.

---

Wondering if it made her pathetic.

---

Wondering if it made her weak.

---

Wondering if it made her selfish.

---

Then hiding the letter because she couldn't bear the idea of anyone seeing it.

---

And now...

the person it was written for had finally read it.

---

Years too late.

---

Mian

"I was fifteen."

---

The explanation sounded ridiculous even to her.

---

Isle shook her head.

---

"I know."

---

And somehow that made it worse.

---

Because there was no judgment in her voice.

---

Only sadness.

---

Isle POV

I looked at Mian.

Really looked at her.

---

And suddenly I saw both versions at once.

---

The woman sitting across from me.

---

And the lonely fifteen-year-old girl who wrote that letter.

---

The girl who feared losing her place.

Feared losing her family.

Feared losing me.

---

A girl carrying burdens she never should have carried alone.

---

My chest hurt.

---

Not because I blamed myself.

---

Because I wished someone had noticed sooner.

---

Final Scene

That night Mian sat alone in her room.

---

The letter rested on her desk.

---

Returned.

---

Safe.

---

For years she had hidden it.

Ashamed of it.

Embarrassed by it.

---

Now?

---

The shame felt smaller somehow.

---

Because Isle knew.

---

Finally knew.

---

Not the polished version.

Not the controlled version.

Not the composed version.

---

The real one.

---

The frightened one.

The lonely one.

The fifteen-year-old girl who had spent years wondering if she mattered enough to stay.

---

Outside the rain began falling again.

---

Soft.

Steady.

---

And for the first time in a long time...

Mian cried.

---

Not loudly.

Not dramatically.

---

Just quietly.

---

For the years she lost.

For the fears she carried.

For the person she used to be.

---

And maybe...

for the person she was finally becoming.

---

End of Chapter 65

More Chapters