Before things could get even hotter and heavier, Donald made one last attempt to stop her. He couldn't just let things go down like this.
"Just one second... Caroline, I really need to tell you that this can't happen. I know we're not as intimate as we used to be, and it may be affecting you. But that doesn't mean things should turn like this. It's a straight road to ruining our relationship."
It was a pretty sound reason. Even Shawn couldn't help but feel a bit guilty for not supporting Donald in keeping the boundaries. Yet he didn't want to let this opportunity slip by.
After all, always having sex while hiding from him was too restrictive. If things kept happening, there might be a point when he got caught red-handed. And he knew if that ever happened, it would break their marriage, even if Donald seemed a bit 'chill' right now.
That was the main reason why he let Caroline be bold, to check how Donald would react to everything in broad daylight. Surprisingly, the older man was doing pretty well until now. Even after watching Caroline kissing Shawn right in front of him, he hadn't exploded.
That made Shawn even more excited about the future.
Meanwhile, Caroline gave Donald a serious look and a pout on her lips. "Are you saying... I'm just doing this because you aren't 'intimate' with me? You really think I'm some kind of lustful, sex-crazed woman? Wow... you've really hurt my feelings."
And to add insult to injury, she released both of their cocks from her grasp, crossed her arms over her breasts, and leaned back against the headboard. "Fine. If that's what you believe, then go ahead. Just pretend I'm a stupid wife who can't control her urges."
She made her expression so convincingly sad that both Shawn and Donald froze. Neither knew if it was an act or if they had actually made her upset.
Of course, Donald felt terrible seeing his beautiful wife so down. The guilt on his face was immediate, and he reached out to hold her hand. "No, no, that's not what I meant. You know I think the world of you, Caroline. You're the most important woman in my life. But..."
"But nothing! If you don't think of me as that, then why did you say those things?" Caroline pulled her hand away, refusing to let it go. She had started off just teasing him but now was truly enjoying how she was messing with him. And honestly, the control she felt was intoxicating.
"Honey... please, don't do this," Donald sighed deeply. "I just want what's best for us, for our relationship."
"What if I told you I just wanted to be closer to both of you... not because I'm frustrated or anything else?" Caroline's tone softened slightly, and she uncrossed her arms, placing her hands on both of their laps again. "What I want is simple: to be loved, to feel wanted, by the men I care about the most."
Donald stared at her, speechless. Her words hit him harder than he expected, especially when she phrased it that way. It wasn't about sex or being unfaithful; it was about feeling connected.
Even Shawn, who had been mostly focused on his own pleasure, couldn't help but feel a little moved by Caroline's words. It reminded him that she had been dealing with a lot too, not just him. He suddenly wanted to give her everything she wanted even more.
"You know what our relation with Shawn is, right?" Donald asked, trying to sound rational despite the situation.
However, Caroline gave him a defiant smirk, her hand stroking both their erections again. "Then he should love me in all ways possible. Like a woman and... maybe more. There's nothing more natural than deep bonding through... intimate gestures."
At this point, Donald was too overwhelmed to argue. His head was spinning, and his body was betraying his moral sense.
When Caroline finally moved her hand into his pajamas and pulled out his fully erect dick, all his thoughts flew out the window. He just let out a guttural moan as her soft fingers wrapped around his hot flesh, stroking him firmly.
She then turned her head and kissed Shawn again, this time while still pumping her husband's cock with one hand. Shawn, on the other hand, slid his fingers between her thighs, teasing her wet, slippery folds with his fingers while she made out with him.
"Ahhh! Ah... so fucking good!" Caroline whimpered between kisses, loving how her pussy was getting wetter with each touch. She then also reached into Shawn's shorts, pulling out his cock so she could stroke it fully too.
It was almost twice the size of Donald's, with thick veins running along its length and a reddish, swollen head that was leaking precum.
For a second, Donald felt another surge of insecurity and jealousy, but Caroline was quick to distract him with her tight grip and fast-paced stroking. He couldn't even focus on Shawn's dick being in his wife's other hand, not when she was making him feel so good.
Soon enough, Caroline broke the kiss with Shawn and looked back at her husband, licking her lips sensually. "How about this? Would you both... let me take your delicious, hard cocks into my mouth at the same time?"
Just hearing that was enough to make Donald grunt and jerk his hips, nearly losing control on the spot.
Meanwhile, Shawn didn't find the idea of sharing Caroline with Donald unpleasant. In fact, he was the one barging into their relationship and had fucked Caroline multiple times behind Donald's back.
Plus, this whole experience was turning him on in ways he hadn't imagined. Seeing Caroline holding two dicks like a true slut and still acting so lovingly made him even harder.
[ Hungry for more? Check my Profile Bio and find my Personal Page through Discord. Character Arts are also Available there. ]