Chapter 8 — Penny's Quilt
Martin had taken up boxing at sixteen and Krav Maga at eighteen, partly because New York demanded a certain practical self-sufficiency and partly because seven years of law school left you with a lot of stress that needed somewhere to go. The result was a level of physical conditioning that tended to surprise people who'd formed their expectations based on the suit.
Two hours later, he was staring at the ceiling of a Midtown hotel room, letting his heart rate finish its return to baseline.
Beside him, Caroline exhaled slowly into her pillow.
"You're still the best at that," she said, to the ceiling.
Martin said nothing. He was in the particular post-adrenaline quiet that he'd learned not to fight — the few minutes where everything went still and the brain briefly stopped filing things.
The city hummed twenty-three floors below. Someone in the hallway walked past with a luggage cart. Somewhere a phone rang once and stopped.
After a while, he got up.
They showered separately and ate the hotel lunch in their bathrobes — room service, because neither of them was dressed and because Martin had decided Caroline needed a meal that wasn't assembled from a bodega at two in the morning. She'd ordered the steak without looking at the price, then seemed to remember, then looked at the price, then ordered it anyway with the expression of someone recalibrating their relationship with money in real time.
He watched her push a piece of it around her plate.
"What's the plan?" he said.
She didn't look up immediately. "The diner. Save what I can. Figure out the next step from there." A pause. "I have a Wharton MBA and I'm calculating how many tables I need to turn per shift to cover a security deposit. It's a weird place to be."
"You couldn't have just applied somewhere in Manhattan?"
"I tried." She set her fork down. "You understand what my last name means right now? Channing? I Googled myself last week and the third result was a Forbes piece calling my father the most destructive financial criminal since Madoff." She said it flatly, the way you talk about weather. "I called twelve people I've known for years. Eleven didn't pick up. The twelfth picked up, said she was so sorry, and then asked me not to call again because her husband's firm had lost money in the fund." She picked her fork back up. "Brooklyn it is."
Martin was quiet for a moment.
The Channing case had been unavoidable in the financial press for two months — a Ponzi scheme of staggering scope, forty-plus years of fabricated returns, losses in the tens of billions spread across hedge funds, pension accounts, endowments, individual investors. The victim list read like a Forbes 400 reunion. Major banks. Sovereign wealth funds. Half the old-money families on the Eastern Seaboard.
Caroline had known nothing about it. That much was legally established and publicly documented. It didn't matter. When a financial catastrophe got that large, the blast radius didn't check intent.
"I can't do much on the formal side," Martin said. "You know that."
"I know."
"Any firm I refer you to, any company I introduce you to — it puts them in an awkward position. Nobody wants to be adjacent to this right now."
"Martin." She looked at him directly. "I know. You got me a job and a bed. You don't owe me anything else." A brief pause. "Genuinely. I need you to let me figure out the rest myself or I'm going to lose my mind."
He recognized this. The specific dignity of someone who needed to believe they were still capable of solving their own problems, because if that went too, there wasn't much left.
"Okay," he said. "But if you need to talk, or things get bad, you call me. That's not negotiable."
She nodded once. Went back to her steak.
His phone rang at twelve forty-three.
Leonard's name on the screen. Martin held up one finger to Caroline, got up, and moved to the window.
"Hey. What's up?"
"So." Leonard's voice had the specific cadence of someone beginning a story they were not proud of. "You know how Penny broke up with her boyfriend? The one from Nebraska?"
"Yeah."
"And she mentioned there was a blanket she left behind that she really wanted back?"
Martin looked out at the Midtown skyline. "Leonard."
"Sheldon and I went to get it."
A long pause.
"And?"
"He's very large," Leonard said. "And now we're on the sidewalk."
"On the sidewalk."
"He took our pants," Leonard said, in a tone of such defeated dignity that Martin had to briefly press his lips together. "Both of us. He just — he grabbed them and we couldn't — anyway. We have our shirts and our underwear and we're on the sidewalk in Queens and you're the only person I could think of who would come get us without making it significantly worse."
Martin rubbed the bridge of his nose. "Text me the address."
"Could you also maybe bring—"
"Yes. I'll bring pants."
He hung up, turned back to the room, and looked at Caroline, who had watched this entire call with the expression of someone who'd had a very strange day and had decided to simply accept whatever came next.
"I have to go retrieve two physicists from a sidewalk," he said.
Caroline blinked. "Are those your roommates?"
"Two of them, yes."
She looked at him for a long moment. "Is your life always like this?"
Martin picked up his jacket. "I'm starting to think yes."
He stopped at a Gap on the way and bought two pairs of chinos off the rack — one 30x30, one 32x32, educated guesses — then had the cab drop him on a residential block in Astoria where Leonard and Sheldon were standing side by side in front of a brick rowhouse, coatless, pantless, with the particular posture of men who had processed their humiliation and arrived at a fragile equilibrium on the other side of it.
Sheldon accepted his pants without comment and put them on with the focused efficiency of someone addressing a variable that had been introduced into his day without consent.
Leonard looked at his and visibly registered that they were a size off. He put them on anyway.
"Walk me through it," Martin said.
Leonard walked him through it. The condensed version: Penny had mentioned a quilt — handmade, her grandmother's, she'd left it at her ex's place during the move. Leonard and Sheldon had gone to retrieve it as a gesture of neighborly goodwill. The ex — Kurt, apparently, former college linebacker, currently employed in a field that did not require de-escalation skills — had responded to their arrival by removing their pants and closing the door.
"Was there a threat?" Martin asked.
"He said he was going to strip us naked and—"
"Okay." Martin looked at the house. "Stay here."
He crossed the street, walked up the front steps, and knocked.
The door opened. Kurt filled most of the frame — six-two, maybe two-thirty, the particular build of someone who'd been an athlete in college and had maintained the mass without maintaining the conditioning. He looked at Martin with the instinctive sizing-up of someone accustomed to winning that calculation.
He registered the suit. Recalculated slightly.
"Who are you?"
"Martin Scott, Pearson Hardman." Martin held out a card. "I represent Penny's interests in the matter of her personal property currently in your possession. Specifically, one quilt."
Kurt stared at the card. "You're serious."
"I'm always serious about property law." Martin stepped forward, and Kurt — more from surprise than anything else — stepped back, and suddenly Martin was inside the living room. He looked around, clocked the quilt folded over the back of the couch, and turned back. "Here's your situation. You're currently in possession of property that belongs to someone else. That person has a legal claim to it. You've already demonstrated hostile intent by assaulting two individuals who came to retrieve it, which — combined with the unlawful retention of the property — is enough to file on."
"It's a blanket," Kurt said. "It's worth like thirty bucks."
"The monetary value of the item is irrelevant to the property claim. What matters is the owner's right to possession." Martin kept his voice entirely conversational. "Now. If Penny files, she wins. The blanket gets returned by court order, plus legal fees. My consultation rate is four hundred an hour. A matter like this, we're looking at roughly three thousand in fees, maybe more if you get creative about contesting it." He tilted his head. "For a blanket."
Kurt's jaw moved.
"Alternatively," Martin said, "you return the blanket. You walk across the street, you apologize to the two men you assaulted — and yes, removing someone's pants without consent qualifies, I've looked it up — and Penny's people consider the matter resolved."
A long silence.
Kurt looked at the quilt. Looked at Martin. Looked at the business card in his hand.
Martin waited. He'd learned from Harvey that silence in a negotiation was not a vacuum you were obligated to fill. You made your argument, you stopped talking, and you let the other person do the math.
Kurt did the math.
"I wasn't trying to—" He stopped. Started again. "Me and Penny. It wasn't — I didn't cheat or anything. We just didn't work out. And then these two guys show up at my door acting like I'm some kind of—" He ran a hand over his face. "I was having a bad week."
"I understand," Martin said. Not it's okay, not that's fine — just acknowledgment. "But the pants were too much."
Kurt looked at the floor. "Yeah."
"Quilt. Apology. We're done."
Another pause. Then Kurt picked up the quilt from the couch and held it out.
Martin took it.
They walked back across the street together — Martin, Kurt, and the quilt — and Kurt stood in front of Leonard and Sheldon on the sidewalk and delivered what Martin had to acknowledge was a genuinely decent apology for someone who'd clearly had very little practice with them. Specific, no excuses in the actual apology part, eye contact maintained.
Leonard, who was constitutionally incapable of holding a grudge for more than about four minutes, forgave him immediately. Sheldon said that he accepted the apology under the provision that no future violations of the social contract would occur, which Kurt processed with the blank expression of someone hearing a language he recognized but couldn't quite parse.
Martin handed the quilt to Leonard. "Get this back to Penny."
"Thank you," Leonard said, with the genuine relief of a man restored to the correct side of a situation. "Seriously. You didn't have to—"
"I was in the neighborhood." Martin straightened his jacket. He looked at Kurt. "Cab fare. Thirty-seven each way, that's seventy-four."
Kurt blinked. Then looked at Leonard. Then back at Martin. "Wait — three times two is—"
Martin stopped. "What?"
"You said thirty-seven each way. Three of you came out here, right? So thirty-seven times three is—"
"It was one cab," Martin said slowly. "One way and return. Thirty-seven plus thirty-seven."
"Oh." Kurt processed this. "So like sixty-something—"
"Seventy-four dollars." Martin pulled out his phone, opened the calculator, and held it up. "Thirty-seven plus thirty-seven. Would you like to verify?"
Kurt looked at the calculator. "Oh. Yeah. Okay."
He pulled out his wallet, counted out seventy-four dollars, and handed it over.
Martin took it. Then looked at him steadily. "And the six dollar tip."
Kurt stared. "The — you want a tip? For your own cab?"
"The driver earned it." Martin held out his hand. "Six dollars."
Leonard was looking very carefully at a point in the middle distance.
Sheldon said, to no one in particular, "The gratuity norm is typically fifteen to twenty percent of the fare, which would place the tip between eleven and fifteen dollars. Six dollars represents a below-standard—"
"Sheldon," Martin said.
"Yes?"
"Thank you."
"You're welcome."
Kurt, with the expression of someone who had lost track of how this afternoon had gotten away from him, produced six more dollars and handed them over.
Martin pocketed the eighty dollars, nodded once at Kurt, and turned back toward the main road to flag a cab uptown.
Behind him, he heard Leonard say, not quietly enough, "Is he always like that?"
Sheldon considered this. "In my observation, yes. Though he usually limits the psychological leverage to cases with higher financial stakes. This may have been recreational."
Martin raised a hand without turning around.
The cab that pulled over had a driver who'd clearly had his own complicated afternoon, and Martin tipped him fifteen percent.
[Chapter Rewards]
500 Power Stones unlock 1 chapter
10 Reviews unlock 1 chapter
Hope you enjoyed the chapter.
20+chapters ahead on P1treon Soulforger