Why has it turned out like this?
She had finally found someone she loved, and for the first time, that person was showing her true self. These two happy occasions overlapping should have brought twice the joy. She should have been experiencing a blissful, dream-like time.
But why... why did it end up like this?
How is Emily so experienced!? Just how many times has she done this!?
Looking at Fairy, Erimi wanted to cry but had no tears left. While she wasn't looking, had Emily already turned into... this?
Erimi closed her eyes, unable to watch Rin claim Fairy, but the lewd, high-pitched moans leaking from Fairy's throat forced her to look back.
So cute. Emily is so cute.
Watching Erimi's internal struggle, Fairy wanted to laugh, but she couldn't. She didn't have the spare energy anyway, as Megumi was already guiding Rin toward her rear.
"Mmph!? ~~~"
Erimi's eyes went wide as she watched the curve of Fairy's flat lower abdomen slowly bulge outward. Comparing Rin's manga-sized cock to Fairy's petite frame, Erimi swallowed hard. It wasn't hunger; it was worry.
"Doesn't... doesn't it hurt?"
"It does a little at the very start... but it feels so good right after," Fairy whispered shyly, looking away. Soon, she was too far gone to be embarrassed. Erimi felt sprays of warm "rain" hitting her face as Fairy's cries grew more melodic.
Erimi didn't look away even as the liquid hit her. She had heard these sounds recently over the phone. Fairy had claimed it was a sex machine, but now she saw... the machine was human!?
"Look, Erimi seems to be getting a bit excited," Rin whispered into Fairy's ear with a wicked grin. "It looks like she loves seeing you like this."
"Uwah... eek..."
Fairy let out a short, pathetic cry. Even though this was her plan—to let Erimi witness her being filled like a cream puff—actually doing it was incredibly embarrassing.
Seeing Fairy's state, Sagiri and Megumi closed in on Erimi from both sides.
"You're getting excited watching the girl you love being treated like this?" Sagiri's voice hissed into Erimi's ear, snapping her back to reality.
"What... what are you talking about!?" Erimi struggled, but Sagiri's ropes held her fast.
"Hehe, don't worry about her being in pain. It's actually super-duper-duper good~" Megumi placed her fingers on Erimi's small, flat chest, teasing the nipples, while Sagiri's hand slid between Erimi's spread legs.
"She's definitely excited. Megumi, look, she's getting all slimy!"
"I'm not! I'm not excited! What slime!? Those... those are HIS liquids!!!!" Erimi's face was beet-red. Her face and body were covered in the mess Rin had left in Fairy the night before, and the mess Fairy had just leaked onto her.
It had been scattered before, but now Sagiri and Megumi were rubbing it into her skin and spreading it everywhere!
"How about a game?" Megumi suggested with a devious smile. "Every time you climax, he gives Fairy another load!"
"Exactly!" Sagiri rubbed her fingers together. "If you don't want Fairy to be filled to the brim with cum, you better hold it in."
Even though Sagiri and Megumi weren't lesbians, their experience at these parties taught them exactly how to make a girl come. Biological reactions cannot be suppressed by willpower alone. With every weak point exposed and unable to flee, Erimi could only bite her lip and try to endure the waves of pleasure crashing through her.
But...
"I'm sorry... Emily, I'm sorry... I'm sorry, I'm sorry!!!!!"
Erimi apologized to Fairy while her back arched in a violent orgasm.
"That's one~" Sagiri took a marker and drew a tally mark on Fairy's thigh, right where Erimi could see it, before returning to work on Erimi's body.
"SORRY! I'M SORRY! SORRY!!!!!"
With only her neck free to move, Erimi shook her head helplessly, crying out apologies as Sagiri and Megumi pushed her over the edge again and again.
"Sorry... sorr—!!!!"
By the time the first "tally" (the character '正') was completed on Fairy's thigh, Erimi's blue eyes were glazed and hazy. Her red hair was plastered to her forehead and cheeks with sweat.
Seeing she had reached her limit, Rin signaled the girls to stop. He lifted the disheveled Fairy and brought her close to Erimi's face. Rin had been focusing on Fairy's ass, so her front was still relatively clean.
"No need to say sorry. The more you come, the happier Fairy gets," Rin said, pressing Fairy's crotch almost against Erimi's nose.
"You're a girl too. You can see how happy and expectant she looks, right?" Rin's voice turned darker and more playful. "But... it bothers me that you keep calling my Fairy 'Wife'."
Erimi stared blankly at the dazed Fairy. Even though Rin hadn't come inside her yet, Fairy was on the verge of losing consciousness.
"Then... I..."
Before Erimi could finish, Rin cut her off.
"I'm not some NTR villain who just steals women. Since you claim she's your wife, I should get your permission before I do anything serious. Do you give me permission to truly 'eat' her?"
"Truly... eat her?" Erimi stammered. "What does that mean?"
"Simply put, Fairy is still a virgin," Sagiri added maliciously.
"Eh?"
Erimi froze. Fairy was a virgin? How? How could she be so experienced and still be a virgin!?
"Don't believe us? Ami, Maki, help Erimi see more clearly."
"Don't look!!!!" The now-conscious Fairy protested with a crimson face. "I... I really am!"
"Words are cheap. Show her," Rin commanded.
With wicked grins, Ami and Maki stepped up, pulling Fairy open so Erimi could see the undeniable proof of her purity. Erimi was at a loss. She thought Fairy had been "used up" long ago.
"Emily... I... what should I... what do I do...?"
"Erimi... say... say you allow it... allow him to eat me," Fairy whispered shyly.
Losing her virginity to Rin on this island—the place where her parents first confessed—was Fairy's plan from the very beginning. That was why she had only let Rin have her ass until now.
Introduce him to the family, confess, then give him everything. The order had to be perfect!
Fairy had originally planned a romantic getaway for just the two of them, but even with five extra people, the result was effectively the same!