She was just a part of the play.
Looking at Emily's lustful face, Erimi realized she was just a prop in an NTR fantasy. Emily wasn't showing her this because she loved her; she was showing her this because Erimi was the "cuckold" character in their drama.
Being a prop was bad enough, but Erimi realized she was even worse than a cuckold. A cuckold at least had the girl before she was taken away. Erimi never even had her.
Erimi sniffled. She didn't even have the right to be "NTR'd."
"Erimi... hurry... say you allow it~"
Fairy was losing her patience. Rin kept teasing the entrance without pushing in, using the friction to drive her crazy while waiting for Erimi's word.
"You have to be specific with your request," Rin whispered. "Who are you, who are you asking, and what are you allowing?"
"Ugh... pervert," Fairy mouthed, but she obeyed. "I... I am Emily Yamada. I am asking my childhood friend Erimi, who always calls me 'Wife'... I'm asking her to allow... to allow Rin's big cock... to be thrust inside my body?!!!!"
"Hehe... better allow it soon. Fairy looks like she's going to go insane~" Sagiri whispered into Erimi's ear while continuing to play with her.
Megumi, Ami, and Maki had slipped away, leaving only Sagiri. Erimi didn't notice their departure; she was hyper-focused on Fairy's face.
"I... I allow it..."
"Allow what?" Rin teased, rubbing against her. "If you aren't clear, I won't know what to do."
"I allow you to put it in..."
"Put what in? Where? How? You have to say it."
Erimi's lip twitched. Does he really want to play this 'Cuckold' role that badly!?
She didn't want to play along, but if she didn't, he would keep edging Fairy until she broke. Erimi thought back to the smut manga she had drawn and whispered through trembling lips.
"Please... thrust your big cock... inside... and fill her... like a cream puff..." Erimi's voice was barely audible.
"Can't hear you. Louder."
Erimi paused, then repeated it a bit louder.
"Still can't hear you! Too quiet!"
Bastard!!!
He could hear her perfectly! He just wanted her to scream it out loud! There was no one else on the island anyway.
Giving up on her dignity, Erimi opened her mouth and shrieked: "PLEASE FILL MY WIFE LIKE A CREAM PUFF, AAAAHHHHHH!!!!!!!"
Satisfied, Rin slowly sank himself into Fairy's petite body right before Erimi's eyes. Erimi watched as Emily's lower belly began to bulge with Rin's shape, and a faint streak of red leaked out.
She heard the wet, squelching sounds, smelled the musk of male and female mixing, and felt the hot "rain" splashing her again.
She gave up. Erimi, who didn't even have the right to be cuckolded, gave up completely. She knew Fairy did this to make her move on. Fairy wasn't gay, so she staged this absurd party to reject her as clearly as possible.
But that wasn't the whole plan. The goal was to reject her, yes, but the ultimate goal was to "straighten" Erimi out.
Erimi was different from Hinata or Saya. They were only "gay" because the person they loved happened to be a girl. Erimi actually had a preference for women. But Fairy knew Erimi wasn't a "hardcore" lesbian; she was just afraid of men and had spent her life drawing "soft, cute girls."
If Rin "trained" her, he could flip her switch. But that would come after the NTR party.
Since it was an NTR party... there had to be more than one "bull."
A moment later, Ami, Maki, and Megumi returned to Erimi's view, but...
"WHAT THE HELL ARE THOSE THINGS!???"
Erimi's eyes shifted from Fairy to the other girls. They had stripped off their swimsuits, but they were all wearing... dildos!?
An NTR party needed multiple bulls, but they couldn't bring in strangers, so the girls had to play the part. Rin nearly burst out laughing at the sight of the massive toys strapped to their petite bodies. Maki glared at him, looking like she wanted to use the strap-on on him, but Rin wasn't into that.
"Wait, wait, wait, wait a minute!!!!!" Erimi panicked. "Are you going to use those on me!?" She was tied up and completely defenseless.
"Your first time is mine~" Sagiri whispered, rubbing her hand between Erimi's slimy legs.
"No... no..." Erimi shook her head. If she had to lose it, she'd rather lose it to the same thing that was taking Emily!
Sagiri was just teasing; she wasn't actually interested in Erimi's virginity yet.
Rin laid Fairy down on the mats, letting her sit on top of him. He held her waist and turned her around. Ami and Megumi stepped up, pinning Fairy's shoulders down.
Gulp... Fairy swallowed hard. "Is this... really okay?"
"Don't worry~" Ami patted her. "It only hurts for a second~"
The girls looked at each other. "3... 2... 1..."
"No—"
Before Erimi could finish her protest, Ami and Megumi put their full weight onto Fairy's shoulders, pushing her down hard.
"Gah...!!!!"
Fairy's neck arched back, her eyes rolling toward the ceiling as veins popped on her forehead. Her abdomen bulged even further as she was forced down to the hilt. She collapsed against Rin's chest.
"EMILY!!!!" Erimi screamed in concern.
After gasping for air, Fairy slowly sat back up, leaning on Rin's chest. Damn, Rin thought, thank god for System Reinforcement. Without it, she'd be broken. This "forced bottoming" had become a regular part of their play ever since Ami and Maki accidentally did it during a prank.
"Hah... hah... hah..."
Fairy panted, her skin a deep, flushed pink. She finally knew what it felt like to be completely, utterly filled.
"I'm fine... I'm okay..." Fairy patted her distended belly and looked at Erimi. "I didn't think it would be... this intense..."
"I told you it was fine! But there's better stuff coming~ It feels even better when both sides are full. Fairy, flip over..."
Fairy obeyed Ami and got on all fours. She couldn't raise her hips much, but it was enough. Ami knelt behind her, adjusting the strap-on. Megumi stepped to the side, letting Fairy grip her toy for stability.
Then Maki, standing behind Ami, gave Ami's butt a hard shove.
"EEEEEK!!!!" Fairy's body buckled.
"Stop! Please stop! Emily is going to break, AAAAAHHHH!!!"
Erimi tried to stop them, but she soon lost the ability to speak.
The party was just beginning. Sagiri hadn't joined the others yet; she had a score to settle with Erimi. Erimi had been her rival online for a long time, talking trash and being overall annoying.
Sagiri didn't want the "group" party yet; she wanted to toy with Erimi. She wanted to force Erimi to reach a climax of pure humiliation while watching her crush being ravaged. That way, she could mock Erimi for the rest of her life!
Erimi tried to resist the pleasure Sagiri was inflicting, her eyes glued to Fairy. She watched as the group shifted from Male-Female-Female to Female-Female-Male, then to a chaotic tangle of bodies.
Because they were all so petite, they could stack together in ways Hinata or Suzu never could. Erimi's gaze shifted from worry to a hollow, Thousand-Yard Stare—just like the "cuckold" in a manga staring at a screen in the final panels.
She had given up completely. Now, it was time to turn her straight!