Chapter 2: Fitting the Mask
[Beacon Hills Gym — September 13, 2011, 5:08 AM]
The boxing bag didn't hit back, which was the only reason Jackson kept standing.
His form was garbage. He knew it — his right hook dropped too low and his left jab had no snap to it. Jackson Whittemore's body was built for lacrosse: fast-twitch muscles, good cardio, aesthetically maintained. It was not built for a fight. The shoulders were too tight. The hips didn't rotate properly. The footwork defaulted to lateral shuffles instead of pivots.
He'd been here forty minutes. His knuckles were raw under the wraps he'd found in Jackson's gym bag, and sweat had soaked through the grey t-shirt he'd grabbed from the closet in the dark. The gym at this hour was empty — just fluorescent light and the smell of rubber mats and his own labored breathing echoing off the walls.
Again.
Right cross. Left hook. The bag barely swung. His wrist ached from an angle he wasn't correcting because he didn't know enough yet to correct it. What he knew about fighting came from watching — movies, MMA clips, the show itself — and watching turned out to be almost useless when translated to actual muscle and bone.
He ran after that. Treadmill, six miles per hour, which should have been easy in a sixteen-year-old athlete's body but became hard at mile three because Jackson's endurance was built for sprinting, not distance. Lacrosse players covered ground in bursts. What was coming would require stamina.
Peter Hale can run down a deer. Derek can chase cars. Scott, once he's bitten, will leave you in the dust without breathing hard.
Jackson pushed the speed to seven. His lungs burned. He kept going.
By 6:30, he was showered and dressed in clothes from Jackson's closet — fitted henley, dark jeans, leather jacket that cost more than a used car. He studied himself in the locker room mirror and practiced the expression: bored superiority, mouth set in a line that dared people to bore him further.
The Porsche started on the first turn. The engine sound was absurd — a mechanical purr that vibrated through the seat — and for three seconds, Jackson let himself enjoy it. The steering was tight. The acceleration was instantaneous. He pulled out of the parking lot and pointed the car toward school and let the machine carry him toward a day he wasn't prepared for.
[Beacon Hills High School — 7:45 AM]
Lydia was waiting at the entrance.
She stood with her bag over one shoulder and her phone in her hand and her posture arranged in a way that made it clear she'd chosen this exact spot for maximum visibility. The strawberry-blonde hair from the photos was pulled back today, and she wore a dress that somehow managed to look both casual and deliberate.
She kissed him. Quick, territorial, tasting like lip gloss. Her hand cupped the back of his neck and squeezed once — affectionate or possessive, depending on interpretation.
"You're early," she said. "That's new."
"Couldn't sleep."
"Hmm." She fell into step beside him, heels clicking on the concrete. "So — lunch with Amanda and Harley, you cannot bail this time, she's still upset about the beach thing. After school I need you at Macy's because the homecoming committee wants input on centerpieces and if I have to do it alone I will choose something hideous on purpose. Saturday we're doing dinner at Rosario's, seven-thirty, and your outfit needs to not be the blue shirt because I'm wearing blue."
She delivered this without pausing for breath or consent. Jackson listened and filed each obligation into the mental calendar he was building.
"Got it."
"Also—" She stopped walking. Her eyes tracked across his face the way a jeweler examines a stone for flaws. Her head tilted one degree to the left.
"What?" he said.
"You just said 'got it.' No argument. No eye-roll. No counter-proposal for ditching the centerpiece meeting." Her lips pressed together. "Are you sick?"
"I told you. Bad sleep."
Lydia studied him for two more seconds, then resumed walking. "Fine. But if you're coming down with something, stay out of kissing range. I have a GPA to protect."
She hooked her arm through his and steered them through the front doors, and Jackson let himself be steered, because the performance demanded it and because Lydia Martin was — even now, even at sixteen, even when she was hiding her intelligence behind gossip about centerpieces — terrifying in the way that brilliant people were terrifying when they decided to pay attention.
She'd noticed something. She couldn't name it yet. But Lydia Martin had one of the highest IQs ever tested at Beacon Hills High, and she'd spent a year and a half studying the original Jackson's patterns with the obsessive attention she brought to everything.
Jackson gave her a smile — warmer than the original would have managed. "Blue dress. Not the blue shirt. Rosario's at seven-thirty."
She squeezed his arm. "You're learning."
He was. Just not the things she thought.
---
[Beacon Hills High — Between Classes, 10:20 AM]
Danny caught up with him in the hallway after second period. Tall, easy grin, backpack slung over one shoulder. He moved through the crowd with the kind of quiet confidence that came from being universally liked — which, in a high school hierarchy built on fear and status, was its own form of power.
"Dude." Danny bumped his shoulder. "Tell me you did the chem reading."
"Most of it."
"Most of it meaning you opened the textbook, or most of it meaning you read the title?"
"The title was very informative."
Danny laughed. Genuine, warm, the kind of laugh that invited participation. They walked together down the hall, and Jackson matched his pace and tried to perform the easy rhythm of a friendship he hadn't earned.
"So," Danny said, "Wilson told Harrison about the thing at Brad's, and now Harrison's telling everyone you—" He stopped. Grinned. "—You're going to make me say it?"
Jackson had no idea what Brad's was. No idea who Wilson or Harrison were beyond names in a contact list. No idea what "the thing" referred to.
He laughed. Short, dismissive, the way Jackson would. "Harrison can talk all he wants."
Danny's grin flickered. Not much — a micro-expression, the corners of his mouth tightening for half a second before the smile reset. He glanced sideways at Jackson with something that wasn't quite suspicion but lived in the same neighborhood.
"You okay, man? You've been... different today."
"Different how?"
"I don't know. Just... different." Danny shrugged, but the shrug was calculated — casual enough to drop the subject while making it clear he hadn't actually dropped it. "Forget it. You coming to the lab after lunch?"
"Yeah."
"Cool." Danny peeled off toward his locker. He raised a hand without looking back.
Jackson watched him go. Danny Mahealani had been Jackson Whittemore's best friend for years. They'd grown up together, shared secrets, built the kind of bond that survived Jackson's worst behavior because Danny was patient enough and loyal enough to see through the armor.
That bond didn't belong to Jackson. Not this Jackson. He'd inherited it like a stolen watch — beautiful, functional, and not his.
The hallway crowd pushed around him. Someone's backpack caught his elbow. A girl he didn't recognize waved, and he gave her the Jackson nod — chin up, minimal acknowledgment, keep moving.
Two days until the preserve.
The bell rang. Jackson turned toward third period and let the current carry him.
---
[Parking Lot — 3:15 PM]
The Porsche's leather seat was warm from sitting in the sun all day. Jackson pulled the door shut and sat in the silence for a full minute, decompressing. His face ached from performing — eight hours of short answers, calculated expressions, social navigation through conversations where every reference was a landmine.
He pulled out Jackson's phone and opened the text threads.
Lydia: centerpiece meeting moved to Thursday, you're free. you're welcome.
Danny: harrison's version of the story is WAY better than what actually happened. ask me monday.
Three group chat notifications he skimmed and archived. A text from David Whittemore about a dentist appointment he needed to confirm. Two Instagram notifications from an app Jackson had barely used.
He scrolled further. Past the social noise, past the logistics of a teenager's life. Down to the contact list, where he tapped through names and matched faces to futures.
Scott McCall. Never texted. Jackson's contact list had him filed without a last name — just "Scott (lacrosse)" — the way you'd label someone who existed in your orbit but not your life. In two days, that boy would walk into the preserve with Stiles Stilinski looking for a dead body, and an Alpha werewolf would find him instead.
Stiles Stilinski. Not in Jackson's contacts at all.
Derek Hale. Obviously not. Derek was twenty-three, living in the ruins of his family's burned house, and wouldn't show up at the school for another week.
Jackson closed the phone and started the engine. The Porsche pulled out of the lot and he drove with the windows down, warm California air filling the car, and for thirty seconds he let himself feel the absurdity of it. Sixteen years old, driving a car that cost six figures, wearing a face from a television show, three days away from the moment everything in this town started dying.
The sun was still up. The street was lined with oak trees casting long shadows across the asphalt. Someone was mowing their lawn two blocks over, and the sound of it — ordinary, mechanical, domestic — hit him in a way he wasn't prepared for.
He turned left toward the Whittemore house, already planning tomorrow's workout schedule, already mapping the week ahead. The preserve. The half-body. Scott's scream in the dark.
Jackson parked in the driveway and sat with the engine off, scrolling through Jackson's texts one more time. Names and relationships and petty dramas. In two days, none of it would matter the way these people thought it mattered. But they didn't know that yet, and Jackson couldn't tell them without destroying everything.
He locked the car and went inside. Margaret had left dinner in the oven — roasted chicken, green beans, a note that said Dad working late, heat at 350 for 10 min. Love you.
Jackson ate standing at the counter because sitting down felt too permanent, and the chicken was good, and the kitchen was quiet, and somewhere across town a boy named Scott McCall was doing homework without any idea that his life had an expiration date stamped three days from now.
The phone buzzed. Danny again: seriously though are you okay? you were weird today.
Jackson typed: I'm fine. Just thinking about stuff.
Danny: ...you're thinking about stuff? who are you and what did you do with jackson whittemore?
Jackson stared at the screen. Deleted two responses before settling on: ha ha. see you tomorrow.
He set the phone down, finished the chicken, and washed the plate. Then he went upstairs, sat at Jackson's desk with Jackson's laptop, and opened a blank document.
He typed for two hours. Everything he remembered. Every season, every death, every betrayal, every creature, every power. The timeline of six years of supernatural warfare compressed into bullet points and shorthand only he could decode. When he finished, he encrypted the file, named it LACROSSE STATS 2011, and buried it three folders deep.
Then he pulled up the calendar. Friday night. The preserve. Police cars gathering for a half-body search, and in the trees beyond the searchlights, an Alpha waiting to change the world.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0