Cherreads

Chapter 7 - How could Zhuge Liang pretend not to see Fa Zheng's revenge?

Why Must We Understand Social Grace and Human Relations?

Many people recoil at the phrase "social grace and worldly wisdom" and dismiss it as hypocritical and superficial. In truth, what you hate is not social intelligence itself — you simply hate not knowing how to use it properly.

The root of suffering in relationships often lies in this: you believe that as long as you work hard and stay reliable, your company will naturally notice you. Yet after three years, the one who gets promoted is the colleague who knows how to dine with the boss and speak to people in their own language. You complain in anger, "These people are so fake," but that only reveals your own misunderstanding.

Where there are two or more people, there is a social arena. Knowing how to get along with others and speak tactfully is not hypocrisy — it is the ability to navigate the world with grace and poise.

Society is not a place ruled purely by reason, and the workplace is even more a field of relationships. The law of the strong requires us to keep our kind nature, yet also know how to hide our edge and stay modest.

Masters of relationships always speak to the point without making a show of it, put others at ease quietly, and never fight for victory or defeat — yet everyone is willing to cooperate with them.

The highest realm of social grace is to get things done while also helping others succeed. For one to go far in life, strength, ability, and good connections are all indispensable.

Why Did Zhuge Liang Ignore Fa Zheng's Acts of Vengeance?

After Liu Bei seized the Shu region, Fa Zheng became one of his core advisors. However, he began taking revenge on those who had offended him in the past, even imprisoning and torturing some to death.

Many people complained to Zhuge Liang, but he chose to ignore it, saying: "When our lord was at Gong'an, he faced Cao Cao in the north, Sun Quan in the east, and even the risk of unrest from Lady Sun at home. Fa Zheng protected our lord like a pair of wings, allowing him to grow and act freely. How could we restrict him over such trivial matters?"

Behind this lay three layers of political wisdom:

Balancing the bigger picture After Liu Bei's forces entered Shu, it was necessary to balance the old Jingzhou faction (Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhuge Liang) and the new Yizhou faction (Fa Zheng, Li Yan). Fa Zheng was a key figure Liu Bei heavily relied on. Suppressing him would be a slap in the face to Liu Bei and alienate the Yizhou elite. Sticking to one's authority Zhuge Liang was in charge of formulating laws, while Fa Zheng's personal conduct fell directly under Liu Bei's jurisdiction. Overstepping this boundary would have been politically immature. Ignoring trivialities for major goals Compared with consolidating the regime and fulfilling Liu Bei's hegemonic ambition, Fa Zheng's revenge on a few enemies was insignificant. Tolerating minor flaws is the hallmark of a mature statesman.

As an ancient saying goes: "When water is too clear, there are no fish; when a man is too exacting, he has no followers."

Zhuge Liang focused on his grand mission rather than competing with Fa Zheng for momentary favor. After Fa Zheng's early death, he took full control of state affairs and became the regent entrusted with Liu Bei's last will.

The Governance Dispute Between Zhuge Liang and Fa Zheng: Strict Law or Lenient Rule?

After Liu Bei conquered Shu, Zhuge Liang enacted harsh laws and launched strict crackdowns, stirring public discontent.

Fa Zheng objected: "Liu Zhang never enforced such strict laws. If we continue this way, we will arouse popular anger!"

Zhuge Liang retorted directly: "Liu Zhang collapsed precisely because his laws were too loose. If we follow his example, we will repeat his failure!"

This exchange is inscribed on a couplet in the Temple of the Marquis of Wu: "Without judging the times, both leniency and severity lead to error; May future rulers of Shu reflect deeply."

It reveals the core logic of governance:

Tough laws in chaotic times Liu Zhang's weakness had thrown Yizhou into chaos, with subordinates betraying their lord (e.g., Zhang Song and Fa Zheng once plotted to replace him). After seizing Shu by force, Liu Bei had to use strict laws to suppress hostile forces and establish authority. Balancing leniency and severity The Zuo Zhuan states: "When governance is too lenient, people grow arrogant; when arrogance arises, correct it with severity. When severity causes suffering, ease it with leniency."

Zhuge Liang not only punished criminals with penalties but also honored model citizens to set examples. He formulated codes of conduct including the Eight Duties, Seven Prohibitions, Six Fears, and Five Dangers, making boundaries clear for officials and the people.

History proved this strategy effective: the people of Yizhou quickly accepted Liu Bei's rule, and the region prospered — so much so that even Cao Cao and Sun Quan envied its stability.

Workplace Insight: The Authority of Firm Action and the Wisdom of Knowing People

The text also mentions that when Liu Bei inspected Guangdu, he found Jiang Wan, the county magistrate, drunk and neglecting his duties. In a fury, he immediately ordered his execution.

This story of "righteous wrath" reminds us: Managers must combine authority with the insight to recognize talent. For ordinary people, the lesson is even clearer: "Without humility, even great men cannot help you; without broad vision, you will never find a patron."

Social grace is not slickness — it is acting in accordance with the rules of the world after seeing through them clearly.

More Chapters