Cherreads

Chapter 36 - Mr Sullivan Apologises

Amy was called out of English ten minutes into the lesson. Her stomach dropped instantly from fear she hadn't done anything wrong or at least, she didn't think she had.

Mr Sullivan paused mid-sentence and looked toward the door.

"Amy," he said gently, "could you step outside for a moment, please?"

Every head turned including Chloe's and Jamie's.

Again.

Heat crawled up her neck as she closed her book and stood. The scrape of her chair felt too loud. Chloe caught her eye and gave a small nod. Jamie mouthed, You've got this.

Amy wasn't sure she did. But made her way to the door thinking of the worst possible outcome which was that Kelsey had made up some lie from what happened at lunch that day just to get Amy in trouble or maybe Xander, Holly or Freya will come into the equation.

The corridor felt colder than the classroom. Quieter. Like the air itself was holding its breath.

Mr Sullivan closed the door behind them.

For a moment, he didn't speak.

Then he exhaled slowly, rubbing a hand over his face.

"I owe you an apology," he said.

Amy blinked.

"Oh."

"I handled that reading session badly," he continued. "Very badly. I should have stopped it the moment it started. I should have protected you. But instead even though I crumbled under pressure, I heard Kelsey say for you to go first and at that moment I wasn't thinking. All i thought was we was doing it. I thought Kelsey was doing us all the hard job and i now look at it and now i look at it thinking she just wanted to embarrass you."

Her throat tightened.

"I didn't want to draw attention to it," he said. "I thought staying neutral would help. But silence doesn't stay neutral—it sides with the loudest voice. And that wasn't fair to you."

Amy stared at the floor tiles, suddenly very aware of how close her hands were to shaking.

"I thought maybe..." she hesitated, then forced the words out, "that it was my fault. For standing up there. For trying."

Mr Sullivan shook his head immediately.

"It wasn't," he said firmly. "Not even a little. We are all starting in the same place, some might learn this quicker than others but we all stumble at some stage."

He waited until she looked up.

"What you did took courage. What failed you wasn't your voice—it was the adults in the room."

That sentence settled into her chest and stayed there.

They walked back into the classroom together.

Mr Sullivan cleared his throat.

"Before we continue," he said, "I need to address something."

The room went quiet and everyone looked towards the front to see both Amy and Mr Sullivan standing at the front.

"I allowed disrespect in this classroom last week," he said evenly. "That was wrong. This is meant to be a safe space, not a stage for humiliation. From now on, it will be treated as one."

His gaze flicked briefly toward Kelsey.

"If anyone mocks, whispers, or tears someone down for sharing their work, there will be consequences."

No one laughed.

No one whispered.

Amy sat down slowly, her pulse loud in her ears.

It wasn't relief she felt.

It was something heavier.

Validation.

Later, during independent writing time, Mr Sullivan paused beside her desk.

"I'd like you to consider entering the school writing competition," he said quietly.

Amy froze.

"I don't know," she replied honestly.

"I do," he said. "And if you choose to try again, you won't do it alone."

Then he walked away, leaving the choice sitting between her hands.

At lunch, Chloe nearly collided with her.

"What did he say?" she demanded.

"He apologised," Amy said.

Chloe stared. "A teacher apologised?"

"Shocking, I know."

Jamie nodded solemnly. "Rare character development."

Amy smiled, surprised by how easily it came.

That evening, she sat on her bed with her notebook open.

She flipped through old pages—stories she'd abandoned, sentences she'd once believed in, words written by a version of herself that hadn't learned to doubt yet.

They weren't perfect.

But they weren't worthless.

They were proof.

She turned to a clean page and wrote:

Sometimes people fail you.

Sometimes they try to fix it.

Sometimes you learn you were never asking for too much.

She didn't cross it out.

A knock came at the door.

Mrs Carter stepped in quietly and sat beside her.

"Chloe told me," she said. "About today."

Amy nodded.

"I'm proud of you," Mrs Carter said. "Not for being strong. For being honest about being hurt."

Amy leaned against her, notebook still open in her lap.

For once, she didn't feel like she was shrinking.

She felt seen.

And that felt dangerous.

And powerful.

And just enough to keep going.

More Chapters